Achieving Grace
alexkrupp.typepad.com
alexkrupp.typepad.com
I think a better structure for this article would have been to make a good case for what "grace" is and why it matters, and then, once that concept is established, give examples of how "grace" is achieved by rowing... But even then, this would have been fairly hand-waving.
I may just be blasé about this, but it seems to me that the central point of this article is ultimately quite weak.
I used to be a runner. I often noted others' running styles and how fluid their mechanics were. I felt you could tell who was was a runner. They _float_. Other people might jog/run once a week -- which often isn't enough to teach your body to move without effort.
When racing, if someone made a move, I'd follow or if I moved, they followed me.
During the race, you wanted to make them pay. At the finish line, they made you better and you made them better, often the result of competition and you rarely end up in first. I can kind of see what he's hinting at.
It seems like an interesting topic to discuss...deconstructing a blog post less so.
My point was that unless you learn to do this, it's very difficult to achieve success as an athlete. So devoting yourself to sports sort of encourages a certain level of spiritual development.
In a related matter I see that Sidwell Friends does play football. I had been wondering about that. Here in Washington State, the best small private high schools don't.
"Mandatory sports" means "mandatory team sports", I presume. Schools don't want students to be in shape, they want students to feel loyalty towards their alma mater.
I agree that ambiguity should be removed, but that's a conversation for another day. I don't feel this particular story warrants it.
- the author does not define "grace"
- the author does not define "sports"
- the author does not define "schools"
Sure, the text is not ambiguous at all!
Maybe I am just being a pedantic academic, but in Math if you want to make a point using X, Y and Z, you usually start be defining X, Y, and Z. Human language is vague already, there's no need to make it even worse.