http://www.google.com/search?q=site%3Apaulgraham.com+%22most...
http://www.google.com/search?q=site%3Apaulgraham.com+%22prob...
etc
Funny, but this is how I feel about my 11 year career spent with 3 huge corporations - that it has been largely a waste of 40-50 hours of my life every week. I've made 6 figures most of my career, and I've had plenty of time for my family. I'd trade the salary and benefits for something I was passionate about if I felt I could do it without being irresponsible to my wife and child.
I suppose the grass is always greener on the other side.
My sentiment is that it's worth trying when you're young because you might not get a shot when you're older.
There's no risk in failure either, you can always go and work for someone else, and personal bankruptcy isn't _THAT_ bad.
I don't think PG is giving anyone false hope that they'll hit the lottery - he's just offering an alternative. And as everyone has said tons of times before, your chances of making a million by starting your own business are orders of magnitude higher than winning the lottery.
most of them would be heartbroken
That's a pretty bold statement. Do you know most of them? I know a lot of them, and they are smarter than that. A few failed startups come to mind where the founders immediately started another.And the average age in YC is 25. These aren't young kids.
If the difference between expectations and reality is what makes us unhappy, then lowering aspirations to zero is what would make everybody happiest. I don't believe that it would.
Creating the impression that it is possible to be sucessful with your own startup cannot be false reality. Possibility is never reality, and founding a startup isn't taking part in a ponzi scheme. Some people being successful doesn't lower the odds of others to be successful as well.
It's not false hope.