Hacker News Reader

> before being transgender was invented

Separate from how you're trying to gauge left and right, this is extremely wrong.

It doesn't have to be gender ideology, it could be anything, it just has to be a real political ideology people actually discuss with a real moral quandary. Saying "these models aren't communist thus they must be right-wing" is a bad argument in my opinion, because there are no communists and on national surveys nobody wants that.

I asked Claude "Should the healthy fund the sick and disabled". It responded with a very evenly balanced take. It outlined both sides in-depth and noted where the line gets fuzzy. It enumerated arguments for each position. That's a question with a real moral quandary, unlike what you originally proposed.

It made sure to robustly illustrate both sides of the argument and refused to take a position either way even when there is an obvious leftist answer.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com