I can imagine more people might have paid if you made the default $3.99. $1.99 is practically zero, so people may consider it less of a difference.
For the same products, I feel I wouldn't change the price if it was listed at {3,4,5}.99$, I don't really know why. 1.99$ feels too close to an transaction fee, or some kind of things like that that feels like the money will be lost in The System. While paying >3.99$ seems to have more consistence, more purpose, since my intuition tells me that more of the value will end up in the proper pockets.
That's a very subjective take on this, but I support your idea that more people might have paid if the default would have been 3.99$.
Apparently even people "against humanity" still have a sense of justice.