Instagram Isn't a Public Utility - The Industry
theindustry.cc
theindustry.cc
I think there may be a difference in audiences here. You have the literal version of US law, which is what this article appears to be based upon, but you also have people's expectations, which is that companies should not abuse their position with respect to the data they hold.
From an American point of view, the idea that people can form any contract they like with a company presumably makes sense. From a European point of view, there are public limits on what a company can do with data. The Uk is not alone in having a data protection act that absolutely limits the use of data sell on, for example.
This of course brings up the question of which law applies, and companies are very adroit at manipulating this. But it's hardly surprising they aren't so good with public opinion.
My own view is that cloud providers should have a European style data protection act, but that's mostly because I like the law and find it to my benefit. However, even where there isn't a law, if I think my data is being abused, I'm more than happy to call a company out on it.
My counter argument to the one that says: they're a company, they can form any contract they like
is: I'm a free individual, I can protest that.
Why do they alone have that power?
You don't say? Extremism like, "These are somewhat icky, sure, but not in the least surprising." and "When you begin using these services, you enter a legally binding contact with them, defined in the Terms of Service. Clicking “I agree” without reading that document is insanely irresponsible — you could be selling your soul without even realizing it."
If you're wondering why that's extremism, then you need to take a step back and get some perspective about where you lie on the pro-consumer<->pro-business spectrum. In my opinion, the author's views push pretty heavily toward the pro-business side. There are limits to what you can put in an EULA. They're pretty far reaching, but they're there.
Also, you can't simply tell users they shouldn't be upset and expect them to listen. That's not the way people work. You can enumerate bullet points and write lengthy essays until your fingers fall off, but a sufficiently large population of angry users will always have their voice heard.