Hacker News Reader

And you are not even addressing how easily a model could hide all kinds of special treatment - either way - at the whim of its creators, be they the government or some outside "trusted" party

View on HN

Judges can hide all sorts of special treatment too. At least with a model as opposed to a soul we can study it and improve it.

Indeed they can but they are in some ways like an individual model per judge, albeit with a sub-optimal interface and very slow, but at least they are hard to game in mass.

what the judge sees is all public record, and can be appealed up the chain, and ultimately overridden by a pardon.

for a model, we would need all the training data, training method, fine tuning, etc to all be public record, along with all of the operations at inference time.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com