How can you possible say this sort of thing in context of what looks like a millenium prize being solved.
I swear there's nobody blinder than those who won't see.
I swear there's nobody blinder than those who won't see.
The first part of your sentence literally contradicts the second part: "we don't have enough knowledge to know, but I know the opposite".
"seem to be" carries semantic meaning here: I'm stating my interpretation of the situation based on data we have available (which is limited) and my prior.
Put another way: "We can't say that for sure, but my money is on it not being a simple case of intellectual property theft"
No, it's an aggravated case, since it's the same way they got all of their training data in the first place.
Apparently if I use lib-gen, that's copyright infringement and I'm exposed to legal risk but it seems fine to download all of it if your intent is "train an AI" so far.
> We don't have enough accurate knowledge to say [one way or the other], and it doesn't seem to be the case at all [based on our incomplete knowledge].
But it is in no way equivalent to this:
> We can't say that for sure, but my money is on it not being a simple case of intellectual property theft
That is a different sentence.
What exact evidence are you incorporating into your prior to come out with this posterior?
Based on what? Your crystal ball?
In short, I have a well-tuned intuition and a huge set of priors, and applied them to the limited knowledge we have about this situation.
Any way you cut it, this is a major achievement for AI, besotted with human drama over whose prompt should be recognized by the history books.
Is nobody else astounded by this?
Eventually it won't matter. Arguments over whether LLMs are "truly" intelligent are going to be a matter of philosophy, and look a little silly.
“Line go up! That is bad! Planet might become unsafe for human life.”
“Nuh uhh! Malankovich cycles and humans are a drop in the bucket! Krakatoa! See!”
“All of California is on fire!”
“Haha, stupid shrill liberals! Go rake your woke forests! Drill baby drill!”
“Are you kidding?! Look at this graph.”
“That’s just propaganda from the elites of the Build-a-bear group!”
“Do we even live in the same universe?”
“And 5g causes COVID!”
“Oh, I guess we’re don’t.”