Comment by gmueckl | Hacker News Reader

Comment by gmueckl | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

What's wrong with stating my opinion when it's relevant to the topic?

I feel like you are somehow irritated by what I said. Are you personally invested in this discussion somehow?

You have a point in calling me out on jujutsu. I haven't spent enough time looking into it because I have been busy with lots of other things. And I haven't seen any forge-like tooling around it, which further reduced this in my personal priorities. I also got the impression that jujutsu by itself is less scalable than the proprietary jujutsu/piper combo.

The other VCS that I should look into more is Lore. But again, time has been a limiting factor for the past year or so.

You know the really funny thing? I talked to many people with similar skills and experiences as mine and we all essentially have very similar issues with the established open source VCSes.

I had a list of missing features here and it's long and it's boring and I deleted it because it's the kind of stuff that tedious to litigate and what's the point? I'm not here to make anyone switch to something else. I really just hope that we can move past git-as-default into a better era. That's all.

I don't want to stop you from providing your opinion, and looking back, I shouldn't have questioned it the way I did.

I didn't consider, after my own experience switching from the time of CVS and then SVN to git, with the substantial liberation of workflow that it brought, that somebody would not have that experience, but maybe even an opposite one instead. To be honest, I still find that hard to imagine. That's silly of me, but here we are. I apologize.

(Edit: I do want to add that I also reacted to the hyperbole in your previous comments in this thread, which honestly did not help your opinion to come across as particularly well-considered, so that colored my impression of your position and my response to it.)

> I really just hope that we can move past git-as-default into a better era. That's all.

Than I can only recommend to give jujutsu a try, with its git backend, as sacrilegious as it might sound to you. It offers a much saner and more consistent approach to version control, and with with its abstraction over different possible backends, it offers a way out without having to overcome the considerable problem of having to replace git _first_. A better backed can come later.

Depending on what exactly your issues with git are, you might like it, and it could allow you to have a small part in moving past git right now.

I'm usually not one to fall for, or advocate for new-ish tooling, but jj is one of the few that convinced me. I started using it exclusively with existing git repos; colleagues are still using git with the same repos and are none the wiser. I haven't looked back.

But that depends on your list of missing features, I suppose. If they don't match, I'd be curious what they are and why they might not have been picked up.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com