Things like this are a Rorschach test for anybody with a significant ideological bent.

Challenge: “A stopped clock can’t be reliably used to tell the time.”

Group A: “A stopped clock is incapable of displaying the correct time and anybody that says they’ve seen one do so is a stupid lying liar! I saw a pre-release paper that proved it!”

Group B: “I looked at my stopped clock 5 times yesterday, 12 hours apart confirmed with the atomic clock, and it was within 2 seconds of the correct time every time except once. The people that can’t use stopped clocks to view the correct time are dumb dumbs that are looking at them wrong.”