I never said anything about FDR.
> I'm disappointed to see that you aren't engaging with the core observation that Germany's inflationary and deflationary episodes were separated by the better part of a decade.
There isn't much there to engage with. It is difficult for inflationary and deflationary episodes to happen concurrently. It seems quite reasonable to say that politics lags the economy by 10-20 years; that is what we've been watching play out in Europe and the US in the present era - there is a substantial lag between problems developing before it leads to political revolt. It takes a long time for malinvestment to become an obvious downstream problem.
Besides, the Nazis had an economy capable of gut punching the British and French empires then ripping through a chunk of the Soviets before anyone could stop them. If you want to associate that sort of result with deflation then I don't think it hurts the case it is associated with positive economic results. Just a shame that the productive strength was used to build a war machine instead of a better society. Although I will reiterate it probably wasn't the inflation or deflation that mattered.
> Except by funding those businesses, which wouldn't happen in a deflating economy.
It would. The real return is the same as it's always been. It isn't like a deflating economy has less real resources and opportunities. If the businesses aren't making enough returns to justify starting them then they shouldn't be started - it is silly to just start businesses for the sake of it; the unspoken assumption is that they are businesses capable of generating some sort of return.
---
I'm pretty sure people are just making stuff up. There seems to be no argument or evidence given the wild claims that upper class welfare is a good idea and the mathematical evidence is that this is just another tax. I only see "whatever makes sense has been tried before; didn't work. We don't need to provide evidence or an actual explanation beyond that pithy observation, it's just obvious read history". Which is outstandingly weird because usually when economics gets challenged there is a good theoretical argument and a lot of practical case studies up to and including the present.
This seems to be the only topic where the debate was settled a century ago and there isn't any need to justify it, despite that fact that exponential money printing is obviously crazy in theory and practice. And the practical evidence is that deflation is more likely than not associated with better economic outcomes than inflation.