Obviously, it's turtles all the way down! :-) GGP here, just checking in to say I enjoyed your thorough response. Nicely done. Reading it brought back good times I had back in the day on r/DebateAnAtheist (~15 yrs ago now!). I admit I'm weak. I just couldn't summon the will to run through the "First Mover" yet again with a traditionalist apologist - even for old times sake. Athough a classic, it's so, so very... tired. Thank you for picking up the gauntlet.
I'll never understand why traditionalist monotheists love their first-mover so much (and why does it always have to be monotheists? Polys are much more fun). Traditional apologists have obviously played through ALL the standard 'moves' and variants of the first mover dozens of times and know it inevitably ends in an unsatisfying stalemate with anyone who's seen it or, "in modernity", consults their LLM. Maybe apologists keep trotting it out because they must still ocassionally run into someone who hasn't seen it? Or perhaps they just enjoy it, like singing an old, comforting hymn. Anyway, you not only get to play through an old standard, it looks like you're also in for non-responsive tangents and not-at-all-subtle dismissive condescension. Enjoy!