Study Suggests Lower Mortality Risk for People Deemed to Be Overweight
nytimes.com
nytimes.com
Any individual who relies on BMI to decide whether or not they are overweight is doing it wrong.
I seriously don't understand this paragraph. Maybe it's because I'm a geek, but I was always under the impression that the risk of dying was 100% no matter which group you belong to. I don't understand what the author of the article is trying to convey here.
1) People who start dying (eg by developing cancer) might take more than a year, and generally they lose weight when they do so. So even if obesity caused you to be more likely to get cancer and die, it wouldn't show up in this sort of data.
2) People who weigh less may be otherwise unhealthy for other reasons -- this doesn't imply that gaining weight would benefit them. In this sense weight is an effect of some other cause.
3) We may not be measuring "overweight" correctly -- scale weight is different from BMI which is different from body fat% which is different from body density which is different from body volume which is different from other things closely associated with "weight" (and specifically the stuff you gain/lose by eating)
It's the shittiest metric of population health we have ... except for all the others.
Height and weight is always collected. Blood cholesterol ... yeah, not so much. So unsurprisingly everything is related back to it.
Anyhow. I'd be amazed if many of we key-hunters-and-karma-gatherers are in much danger of zooming into the dangerous band at the bottom of the BMI (modulo EDs).
So, given that most people are not rocking pro-bodybuilder fat-free mass indexes, the BMI is still better than nothing.