You're right that we can never be certain a system is generally intelligent by that metric. We can be certain that a system is
not generally intelligent, via counter examples.
I imagine it will be like mathematical theorems that have been computationally verified to some very large n. The longer we go without finding a counterexample, the more certain we will be that it's true, even if we can't prove it formally.
The systems today are extremely easy to find counterexamples for, so are obviously not generally intelligent.