Hacker News Reader

Comment by functionmouse | Hacker News Reader

So if some 14 year old wants to throw up a phpBB instance on his raspberry pi, he should need a license and regulators' noses in his business, like how we extinguish- erm, I mean, controlled HAM radio?

How do you differentiate?

View on HN

If lawyers can't figure out the difference between a 14 year old throwing up an phpBB on a raspberry pi vs equifax, anthropic, meta, etc...idk what to tell you. Get better lawyers, it falls into "laws for hobbyists aren't working part of my comment"

Is HAM radio really extinguished? All it takes is passing a test, and the rules around it seem more valuable to sharing a public resource (frequency spectrum) than detrimental?

HAM radio is dying more from the behavior of its geriatric old guard towards newcomers than any regulation.

The lack of ability to use encryption makes most things I'd think to do on it with packet radio fall off quickly. LoRA seems to be where more digital hobbyists end up because we can do things like build out Reticulum without violating FCC regulations.

But there's still some fun stuff to be done with HAM, as long as you don't mind anyone and everyone listening in on it.

The test is easier than ever too. None of the three levels even require learning morse code anymore. I passed Technician after a few hours of study. General doesn't take much more. Amateur Extra is the hard one, but you can do most things you'd want to with General.

https://hamstudy.org

Scale. In the same way every 10 year old Timmy is not being hauled into court for pirating a few Drake songs, but major piracy organizations seeding millions of songs are, litigation and enforcement does selectively target bad actors based on how big of an issue they are.

Boomers killed ham radio, not regulation.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com