I hate to rain on the parade, but the v2 icons were beautiful -- all perfectly proportioned. Absolutely fantastic. The new ones have to distort things to align to the grid, and wind up looking inconsistent and unbalanced.
I'm comparing the new icons with my downloaded version of 2.0, and, for example, the "i" in the "info" icon is no longer centered. Or, now icons like "asterisk" or "ban-circle" have strokes that are too thick, while "envelope" is too skinny -- since strokes basically have to be 1px or 2px, I guess.
Previously, the icons were drawn in a balanced and consistent way, and all looked good together. Now, their widths and shapes have been shoehorned into a 14px grid that frankly destroys a lot of their charm and consistency.
Pixel-fitting made perfect sense when fonts weren't anti-aliased, but now that almost everyone has even subpixel hinting enabled, it's anachronistic. The FontAwesome team has done a great job with introducing new icons, but it saddens me to see what were once beautifully proportioned icons that showed excellent design taste, now take a giant step backwards.
In a strange way, it reminds me of when IKEA stopped using Futura and started using Verdana a couple years ago. Excellent design being replaced by mediocre design which is more "technologically accessible"...