No it's not. According to your own reasoning that position is defensible as much as any other is.
> Anyone claiming a definite answer one way or the other should show us their Theory of Consciousness which shows why it is the case.
Anyone claiming possibility of consciousness should do the same - show their Theory of Consciousness because without a convincing theory backing their claim, we can freely dispense with it. Otherwise, anyone can claim that anything is "possibly conscious" and we'll have to accept that position because, according to your thesis, without a Theory of Consciousness we can't be sure. Ergo, in that case "consciousness" loses all meaning. I'm not exaggerating, real example from yesterday - some religious figures argued that "floating point numbers are conscious".
My thesis is that the whole "Is AI conscious?" debate as a fat red herring - not the only one by any means, but there is no other rational reason to debate the consciousness of numbers before solving real human, social and economic problems which keep getting worse.