I think you're getting into a false dichotomy where true/false are the only options. You claimed LLMs don't approach human intelligence and LLMs are lossy search indexes. I'm saying: Does that comparison even make sense? Is intelligence not possible given large enough search? What is human intelligence? What does it even mean to approach human intelligence? And as a specific counter-example: Can we prove human intelligence is not a large enough search? (Chinese room covers that so it's not like we'll discover something new here)
I'm not claiming something contrary. I'm raising an example for "Is the context of the claim even well formed and valid?"
(Same applies to your example: What do you mean by god? Is "is" even a valid state for a god?)