All the eggs keep being stored in the same place (same computer) either way, but one gives them a deluxe padded package and the other one wraps a random material around each egg.
You're not convincing a normal person to memorize 20 high quality passwords, and multiple physical devices are going to be put on the same keyring.
So in short, yes.
It is going to get written down. So having multiple is very little extra trouble.
Written down in the same place so we're back to one basket holding all the eggs!