Nothing wrong with human exceptionalism, actually, if we exclude religion, human non-exceptionalism is risky to the point of insanity.
> How about we just admit that we don't know?
How about we admit that we do know? We do know that LLM's don't suffer and we do know that even if they do, it doesn't matter - we do know that animals suffer when they're killed for food, and?
Animals can express their suffering, LLM's cannot - because they don't suffer. If something hurts I don't feel it in my "neural network" I feel it at the point of contact or other organs whose functions are suppressed for very specific reasons. LLM's have no body, no organs, therefore no need to experience suffering. Suffering is a function specifically evolved for specific purposes, it's not an inherent property of all neural nets.
Artificial neural nets feel as much as a nail feels when struk by a hammer - no more. ANN's can fake feelings but they can't feel.