Computer model of the Economy explains its instability
washingtonpost.com
washingtonpost.com
Great example of a thought experiment used to contradict the results of experiments actually carried out under real circumstances. (+ 5 points: http://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/crackpot.html)
Letting traders, market makers, and other market participants make bets on the value of a stock is vitally important. Liquidity is a good thing, highly informed markets are a good thing.
Is it really so terrible that insolvent companies' stocks go down?
An analogy: I did an experiment. I eliminated the "always back up your data" rule for a week. Nothing bad happened. Are you going to come up with thought experiments telling me this is a bad idea, in contradiction of my real experiment?
I don't actually buy the hypothesis, but it isn't technically a thought experiment contradicting a real one.
This is all new to me, and sounds compelling, but I have a question. If the elimination of the uptick rule in mid-2007 is exacerbating market volatility, why don't the market authorities (NYSE, NASDAQ) reinstate the uptick rule on their own?
Is it that they aren't allowed to make their own rules, within the SEC's regulatory oversight? Perhaps they see the increased volatility as a good thing for them? Are they so spooked by the current economic weather that they don't see the larger picture?