Haha, god damn it. I just got done getting all the way off Squarespace after Google Domains pushed me there. It's just a pity not everything is supported by Cloudflare. Okay, anyway, the solution if you're stuck with Namecheap for the moment seems to be to proactively do whatever this ID verification is. Does anyone know? If anyone has managed to do this proactively then I'd love to follow their instructions.