Where have I heard about this before? Oh right, months ago by Ed Zitron.
Where have I heard about this before? Oh right, months ago by Ed Zitron.
Please dont say that name here, the witch hunters will out with their forks!!
Halfway through one episode, he mentioned his contact in the industry who was telling him about how the agents are actually useless and people have to do all this cleanup work to use the output they generate, and of course Ed promised his audience that's the entire industry and that the collapse was imminent.
That was right at the moment that the models were getting so good that we could "one shot" an issue.
I knew then and there this guy was hot air and I never took him seriously since.
Call this pitchforks.
He's definitely not a software guy, and has been dead wrong on the software use-cases for LLMs. They are really, really bad in most other areas though (because we haven't built decent harnesses for broader "knowledge work").
We'll get there, but it'll take a decade or two. My plan is to ride this wave into retirement/death/immanence of the machine god, whichever comes first.
I agree that the first one is sometimes iffy, but even if you think LLMs will replace x% of white collar work by 2030, the second point remains.