It's like the British government trying to enforce tea confiscations on US residents in a way that violates the fifth amendment protections against unreasonable confiscation of private property.
It's like the British government trying to enforce tea confiscations on US residents in a way that violates the fifth amendment protections against unreasonable confiscation of private property.
Byrne reasonably knew that FSIA applies; the point was to get the words on record that allow him to claim a victory in the court of public opinion. Filing the suit was irrelevant, that was the point: it highlights how Ofcom's attempts at enforcement were equally irrelevant and lacking in jurisdiction. Hence:
> All Plaintiffs seek in this action is a declaration that [Ofcom’s] Section 100 Orders, transmitted by e-mail, did not effect valid service in the United States.
No actual damages for the putative violation of rights; just an affirmation that Ofcom was FOS in trying anything in the first place.
And, per Byrne, the court gladly delivered:
> American courts generally decline to enforce foreign judgments that violate the United States Constitution, if indeed Plaintiffs are correct in their constitutional claims.
Byrne and 4chan clearly are correct in the original constitutional claim, and Ofcom has received and will continue to receive $0 of the fines they purport to assess.