UK School Replaces All Textbooks with iPads
bbc.co.uk
bbc.co.uk
As a test-taking tool, an iPad is not terribly effective either. The maths teacher shows that she can quickly aggregate the solutions, but there's no good way for the students to express their thought process. I'm pretty sure by their age, if I had simply written the answer on the paper I wouldn't have been given full marks. It's important to teach students good mathematical form from an early age, and this definitely undermines that. Consider maths is one of the easiest classes to write tests for, I wonder how science, english etc. are getting on - likely a lot of terribly simple multiple choice.
Lastly, everyone seems so smug. The school's administration thinks they've taken this gigantic problem of how to do learning electronically and they've just knocked it out of the park. I know it's a sort of fluff piece, but it'd be better to see a longer video about problems they solved, lessons they learned, etc. As it stands, it looks like a lot of off-the-shelf software cobbled together by a local Apple rep, which is hardly ground-breaking. They've just thrown a lot of money at it. The administrator featured doesn't seem to be overly technical, and the teacher seems more interested in the fact that now she doesn't have to go home and mark things in her spare time ( but, of course, she's 'dedicated', as she says herself ).
> When I was trying to do homework, I wanted - the questions from page 251, the table of equations from 190, and to be able to flip through and find similar examples. Obviously e-books fail miserably if you need quick access to multiple pages.
The solution to this could be implemented in under a week, for sure. Add a little UI for temporary bookmarks. Let the reader save a set of relevant pages (questions, table of equations, examples) and then swipe between them. Simple.
While improvements to a tablet approach can resolve all of the problems you're mentioning, a regular book will never be regex searchable. A regular piece of paper will never let the teacher know your scores immediately so she can help you past problems and provide instant feedback. A regular set of class books will never decrease the need to linearly increase the number of pieces of paper needed for the amount of materials you want the students to have.
As far as searching, the index at the back of a book is likely more useful than full-text search. Usually I'm not interested in a particular term, but 'that thing that we covered last week, with the Fourier Transform', or something like that. There aren't any keywords, regexes won't help - you need a well-organized textbook where the headings and sub-headings facilitate this kind of searching.
Curriculum changes seem like the wrong way to go as well - if a tablet isn't good for teaching a subject, don't jam the subject into a format the tablet can understand. This is clearest in the testing case, but it's generally applicable: the tablet, as a device, exposes an interface. Paper exposes the ultimate interface: it accepts any free-form input. At best tablets can work in a similar way, but we have a hard time doing anything useful with this input. As we normalize the input to make it easier to process, we move away from a general purpose input device, and we force students to think and express themselves in the specific way we designed the interface to work.
One trick is to screenshot the pages you need to refer to frequently into a photo album. You can also photo pages from paper books for quick reference this way. I also use this trick with map screenshots for journeys where I won't have online access. I used that for a trip to the Lake District.
Another trick is to have each PDF file you need to switch between open in a separate app, then four-finger swipe between them. When you learn that trick it's amazing how well it works. Many of the PDFs I keep in iBooks are also in Dropbox and Google Drive and my most used ones are pinned/starred for local storage so I can easily move back and forth between three different files. This method probably won't work as well for ebooks though. Far from ideal, sure, but I've found it a very practical and usable solution.
It can't replace paper completely, sure, but they are very rapidly becoming indispensable tools in a lot of situations and I think that will soon include education.
Don't forget another important feature of eBooks - you can search the whole book. You can also annotate without ruining the physical copy ;-).
The only problem is books that aren't well made, for example, PDFs without hyperlinks (like "Equation 2.6.1" is not clickable so you have to flip back).
But when it comes to non-fiction/reference books the technology is just not ready. You don't read cover to cover, you bounce around, you mark sections, you take notes, you check your answers in the back, and yet the software I have seen does all of this stuff badly.
Plus whenever people roll out one of these snazzy "look how hip and modern we are" school programs I never read about how much they spent on teacher training or development of researches (apps, lesson plans, etc).
So I always wonder if they literally just turned up with a pack of iPads one day and said to the teachers "make this work!" Without any real thought given to how exactly the teachers are meant to use them.
My kids live on their tablets and computers.
They will have even less problems adapting to that mode of working than we do - and the solutions they have to reproduce useful paper techniques like highlighting and note taking will completely change the picture in high-tech's favor.
On the one hand, the kids aren't hauling 30 pounds of books to and from school everyday, school lockers are pretty much superfluous, and the iPad is a great tool. On the other hand, it's very hard for me as their parent to tell (at a glance) whether or not the kids are actually doing school work or just screwing around and it's very easy for the kids to get distracted if they aren't having a good concentration day.
Like everything else, it's a bit of a mixed bag.
I believe it varies with the teacher and the subject though.
[EDIT] The iPads, not the kids!
You can restrict installing apps, uninstalling apps, using the camera, loading the App Store, talking with Siri, altering settings, etc. See this list for some of the things you can do:
http://help.apple.com/configurator/mac/1.2/#cadbf9e41d
Yet more:
It doesn't really matter with regards to my children. We believe in addressing behavior directly (talking to them, rewarding/punishing behavior, etc). We just told them not to use their iPads for games without asking first (same rules as apply to their laptops), protect your privacy, blah blah blah.
Again, my major beef is that it takes more effort to verify that they are staying out of trouble. It's not impossible, but it's nerve wracking that I can't glance and see that they are doing homework, I have to actually maneuver around and look over their shoulder.
Trust but verify is our motto.
Besides, it's an attitude issue. Preventing them from installing stuff via a setting isn't going to stop a kid from screwing around if they really want to (IMO). We choose to address the attitude and the actual behavior (if and when it occurs).
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2255546/School-spent...
It may not come as a surprise to many people to learn that laptops break almost as often as tablets when deployed one-on-one in schools. A quick Google led me to one study from 2004 in Maine, where over an 18 month period 50% of laptops required repair, and 35% of students experienced laptops breaking down or being accidentally damaged[1].
The main difference is that a higher percentage of tablets require total replacement, which is somewhat understandable as tablets (be they Android or iOS) are far less user serviceable.
[1]: http://maine.gov/mlti/articles/research/PCHSLaptopsFinal.pdf
AFAIK this is caused by eyes drying due to reduced blink rate. All backlit tablets will have this problem.
Therefore, I still buy old-school books and print out material when I need to read it in-depth.
Does no-one else think this is a concern when giving young children tablets as a replacement for non-backlit books?
RS
This is why known a kobo and a computer and nothing else. You just can't read on a backlit device.
I'm in favour of iPads in school. I've ran through a few of the educational programs on the iPad (including iTunes and Udemy as well as textbooks), it's a great resource and helps to consolidate everything I need in one place. When I was at Uni I was one of the few people who used a laptop to take notes in lectures as I found it easier to split my focus.
I can't watch the video but I'm guessing that they've got all the iPads through the enterprise system that most big companies are (or should be anyway) using, which gives them a bit more granularity on what's going on, pushing updates and some additional restrictions. I'm sure teachers are smart enough to realise that kids with fully unlocked iPads are going to spend their time mucking about.
They've spent more than double what they saved on photocopying, not to mention that 840 iPads take a lot more maintenance than five or six photocopiers.
Also, on a more practical level, trying to procure a thousand Nexus 10s is no easy task. I don't think one platform is inherently better than the other in the education market, but it should be pretty self-evident that Apple is better set-up to currently sell into the sector.
Also, in a school setting, how do you expect students and teachers to deal with different versions of operating systems and device specifications?
User experience is not magic. It's something that involves a lot of time and effort on behalf of the apps developers. It does contribute to the choices made by individuals and this filters up to the institution level. How do you think the iPad penetrated the enterprise?
> And fragmentation is hardly an issue when the school is buying all the hardware.
True. However, what happens when the school wishes to use an app that's not supported by the device they purchased? As an Android user I've found plenty of apps that fail on my device while working perfectly on others. Sure there are problems with compatibility with apps on different versions of iOS, but they are relatively minor compared to the problems that I've come across on Android.
Android is very good at many things, but in terms of the education market Apple has been much sharper in getting textbooks and educational content front and centre. I'm sure if there was a level of parity in terms of content and functionality, but Android was significantly cheaper then schools would go that way.
This is kind of sad, because maths-heavy textbooks could be vastly improved if they were properly implemented for tablets.
Man, if I had the time, I'd love to work on a comprehensive solution for this: e.g. an app for studying maths-heavy material by letting you leverage the power of the device while making user interaction at least as good as ordinary paper - and maybe better. Say, you have a maths or physics textbook to study, and you're about to work on exercises. The solutions to these could then be immediately accessible (no need to enter page numbers), along with an editable list of relevant theorems/quantitative relations or wordy definitions. Wolfram Alpha integration would probably work well for many kinds of problems (e.g. calculus, or more basic algebra), to provide checks to solutions, or even to find solutions that the author didn't provide. I bet this sort of stuff can accelerate learning, and it's just the tip of the iceberg.
If this could be done, then you can imagine a physics student graduating with 4 years' worth of textbooks, in-class notes and each and every exercise he/she worked on all properly accessible on one iPad and preserved for the future. (Currently, lots and lots of instructive exercises and worked examples just get chucked out once the course is done.)
Maths-heavy subjects obviously introduce many formatting issues, and there's always the added layer of difficulty due to the constant need for exercises and solutions. As far as I can see though, many of these problems have already been solved in other contexts (e.g. LaTeX) - so maybe they 'just' need to be cleverly wired together and coated with an innovative UI.
Just a thought.
Good good good. Can't have it based on something open, something which can bring things back to the public. That would be counter-productive.
Wasn't the UK supposed to be a frontier country on open data and open data-systems in the public sector or am I mixing things up?
The fact is that the iPad is (or at least was) the best tablet available for them to use, so they used it rather than get trapped in the morass of trying to create hardware or use hardware that wasn't as far along.
In reality, they're validating a model that would make it easier for open source alternatives to flourish down the road.
Which challenges the school chooses to address is a political issue in and of itself. If the goal of the school is to educate students so that they can become outstanding citizens, then it is probably not a good idea to train them that Apple's approach -- with its restrictions and censorship -- is how things should be, which is precisely what they are doing by giving everyone iPads.
Words of wisdom: "The medium is the message."
"they're validating a model that would make it easier for open source alternatives to flourish down the road"
There is nothing about the iPad that helps open source. It is a computer that is built from the ground up to fight against any sort of hacking, tinkering, or user programming. In what world does open source mesh well with "pay us to be able to distribute your programs" or "you are only allowed to program the computer in the languages that we choose?"
So the students can't post an email or blog expressing their open thoughts because it's an iPad? Is so, I'd agree with you.
You more likely mean because Apple doesn't allow one to publish randomly to their app store? If so, then you're twisting the notions of censorship.
Exactly how are regular text books open for modification in schools? Writing in my textbooks was strictly forbidden. Apple's restriction on their app store has nothing meaningful to do with students expressing themselves.
There is nothing about the iPad that helps open source.
The whole tablet market would still not likely have been proven without the iPad. Go back before the iPad was introduced and find the market estimates for tablets. The fact that you could even imagine replacing this school's hardware with something like it that's open source is thanks to the iPad. The iPad VALIDATED the market and many of the concepts built on top of it. Without it, open source or even Android alternatives would still not be here.
On top of all of this, who wants the students hacking on their tablets anyway? That tablet is for distributing information and coordinating with the teacher. The last thing you want is for it to be easy for a prankster to create applications that would facilitate cheating or mayhem. You also don't want a system that is all hacked up with 3rd party app store items riddled with trojans that keeps the students from opening their legitimate apps and learning.
It is not just that Apple has standards for their own app store. Fedora has standards for its repositories, but I would not accuse them of any kind of censorship.
The problem is that Apple has created a computer whose software can only be installed from the App Store, unless you pay Apple a special fee and agree to all manner of unfriendly licenses (on top of those you already agreed to to use your computer in the first place). We are past the point of talking about theoretical risks associated with such a system; Apple already refused to allow political cartoons to run on iPads. If you do not call that censorship, what do you call it?
"Apple's restriction on their app store has nothing meaningful to do with students expressing themselves."
Unless those students happen to be expressing themselves by writing software.
"The whole tablet market would still not likely have been proven without the iPad"
I have my doubts. Apple only marketed their tablet well; they did not invent the technology that made it possible.
"who wants the students hacking on their tablets anyway?"
I do, because like many people, I learned to program by hacking every computer available to me in my spare time. I would not be where I am today if I had not had the opportunity to do so. By surrounding students with computers they cannot hack at will, this school is telling their students that they are not allowed to learn to program in such an unsanctioned way; the students must wait until some teacher comes along to teach them some standardized programming curriculum, and too bad if they had been trying to learn something else. Right now, the students are lucky in that they most likely have a computer to hack at their home; that may not be the case in the future, especially if these sorts of restricted computers continue to gain popularity.
"The last thing you want is for it to be easy for a prankster to create applications that would facilitate cheating or mayhem"
Mayhem? If the school's IT staff cannot deal with the "mayhem" caused by a single computer, they are incompetent.
As for cheating, sure, that's a risk of giving students programmable computers. The answer is not to try to restrict student activities on those computers, any more than the answer to cheating by leaving notes in a bathroom stall is to watch students go to the bathroom. It is not hard to build a computer that can be rapidly reimaged before an exam. It is not hard to deny student's internet access during an exam. It is not hard for a teacher to check for ad-hoc networks during an exam.
Why deny students the ability to learn outside the standard curriculum? Why insist that they must come from families that can afford to buy more computers for them, when you could have the school give them computers to program? We had programmable desktops when I was in high school, and the benefits were clear: there was a club for hackers who just liked to hack (and even a system where they would help maintain the school's network). Back then, we had desktops; it would have been great to have something we could carry around with us.
"You also don't want a system that is all hacked up with 3rd party app store items riddled with trojans that keeps the students from opening their legitimate apps and learning."
Funny how we didn't have this problem at my high school. The reason is pretty simple: misbehaving computers could be reimaged quickly. Students who repeatedly and deliberately installed malware were suspended, no different from students who drew graffiti or broken into other students' lockers.
Your argument amounts to this: students cannot learn unless they are following the prescribed curriculum, so any student who tries to hack the computer that was issued for the prescribed curriculum must be either a cheater, a vandal, or that they will just harm their education by doing things they were not told to do. That is a narrow view of learning and it is the reason so many intelligent kids hate going to school.
They weren't able to modify their textbooks, either.
Buy an iPad case.
> scribbled on them, wrote errata in
Most reading apps have annotations.
> copied pages for people
Not necessary with digital copies.
> ripped out pages, occasionally watched nitric acid dissolve them, accidentally set them on fire
Fundamental to your learning experience, I take it?
> sold them and swapped them
I don't believe these are student-owned textbooks.
> occasionally clunted someone round the head with them
Hardly a necessary feature.
Unless some student loses access to their books because they violated some third-party library's policy about reading their books. I see all sorts of conditions on using electronic books at my university's library -- conditions that are enforced by a service provider, not the university.
Sometimes, RMS can be prophetic:
I do actually use an e-reader (Kobo touch) but it's been hacked to register and remove any network access possibility and only gets DRM free epubs and PDFs put near it.
Annotations with diagrams finely written with pencil or smudged around with a lopping great big finger?
Not possible with certain DRM encumbered digital copies.
It was more of a point that the iPad wouldn't survive GCSE/A level chemistry or a machine shop for instruction whereas a book would even with minor acid or fire damage.
We had to buy our textbooks. I bet that they aren't that generous all of a sudden.
Clunting someone with an A level mathematics textbook end on stopped a mugging. If it was an iPad, you'd be the one being mugged (I grew up in a shitty bit of London)
The cost of supplying 840 pupils with iPads and covers, even at consumer rates, would only be around £350K. From the stated numbers, this would be recouped in saved photocopying bills alone in around five years. Clearly there will be significant software and operations costs, but I would speculate that the less obvious time and material savings (e.g. updating a hand-out from a previous class to reflect new teaching best practices) would more than offset these costs. Centralising resources is a natural side effect of digital distribution, and encourages resource sharing at all levels of the organisation.
It's easy to think up other small but significant wins enabled by this approach. We've probably all had the experience of watching a stand-in teacher struggle to fill the lesson time because the regular guy has become suddenly indisposed. With good systems in place it's easy to imagine this being a non-problem.
TMK its iPads as frontends, Meru Wireless Networks to connect the about 2000 iPads, MS Server 2008 with AD and MS Exchange at the backend.
for more info see: http://www.independent.co.uk/news/education/education-news/t... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=13FO_A0Sokw (plus an Apple UK profile on ESSA) http://www.apple.com/uk/education/profiles/essa/
Seriously, what are the qualifications required for school administrators? These stories give the impression that they're crazily gullible and shallow people, whose decisions are guided more by the latest school-administrator fads than by actual experience with education...
There is a volume licensing program for the App Store, where schools retain ownership and can buy in bulk at a discount (where developers opt in to allow such discounts). But in fairness, distribution still isn't perfect out of the box (it's done via one-time codes on the App Store. It is possible to automate this, but not as standard).
Distraction is another thing (sit on the back and watch to get an idea) but I presume that iPads can eventually be modified to access only coursework.