ME1 is one of very few games that I like despite weak gameplay - I just started playing some Mass Effect, for the first time, a few weeks ago. The writing is indeed fantastic even though the very coarse shape of the story is Halo-like. It's the people, places and organizations that feel real that make it so good. But "dated" is not what I'd call the combat because it was bad at the time of release, too. There have been much better playing first-person shooters much earlier than Mass Effect. On PC Doom, Quake, Half-Life to name a few. On consoles Halo (and probably others, not my scene).