I meant that your use of the phrase "real old stuff should be found, in some form, in other cultures" is not necessarily true. Much of the commonality is based on linguistic studies only and does not include other cultural aspects.
The more important point is that once the cultures diverged into different geographies, they came into contact with other cultures with their own realities/stories which were incorporated into Sanskrit literature and handed down orally while a similar thing did not happen with the others to the same extent.