- BSL4 is really, really stringent, and these requirements and review processes are strictly regulated across the board
- Most modifications researchers are actually capable of, nature is capable of producing something way scarier. Researchers are making tiny tweaks in comparison to the zoonotic exposure in everyday life that has brought us viruses that do things we never imagined
- Most gain of function tweaks weaken some other aspect, for example the way contagiousness and lethality are at odds
- It's considered rather unlikely that COVID-19 came about via gain of function research, despite how much the public wants this to be true
- It is quite useful for research, a lot is learned by doing it
I'm not even necessarily against GoF research, and I mostly agree with all of your points.
I'm asking about GP's logic.
I think different standards can apply.
You should want to know avenues of exploit so you can be defensive with security. You have little control over the offensive side of vulnerability exploitation.
Both lines of research are limited by some sense of waste: in time or money.
When should you stop? When some acceptable standard is reached and a certain amount of risk is accepted.
In the case of GoF, if it wasn't somehow profitable, then the research would likely cease to exist.