Hacker News Reader

Wait. So if I write a review/article about a product the HN link should be changed to point to the product not my review? That makes no sense.

View on HN

If the review is about a casual web game and if instead of reading quotes, your impression and your ads I can experience the game myself then yes we should point to the product.

What ads are you talking about? There are 0 ads on my site!

House ads do count.

You mean, links to other pages on my site?

When they are off topic, yes.

Note that the whole review seems off topic too. It’s neither more interesting nor more accessible than the topic itself.

Dude, the links in that article go to: 1. The review framework used to review the game 2. The game page itself where user can post their own reviews 3. The original game url

I can't see how are these off topic?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com