>They use a tankless water heater so electrical use is ~zero when nobody is using hot water, which is most of the time. If you use a tank - heating ~40 gallons of water 24/7/365 - that's hard to compete with by just being more efficient.
You need to compare this against the average heating days for their location.
Water heaters are a "incandescent lightbulbs are 100% efficient in the winter" situation.