DiscImageStudio: burn visible artwork onto CDs, DVDs and Blu-ray discs | Hacker News Reader

DiscImageStudio: burn visible artwork onto CDs, DVDs and Blu-ray discs

github.com

363 pointsbpierre79 comments

I made a CTF challenge for this year's BSidesSF CTF where players were given a CDDA audio file (just raw PCM samples) which when burned on a CD-RW would produce an image of the flag. (The idea was not for them to burn the audio, since they'd need to guess my exact CD-RW or else they wouldn't get an image readable enough to be useful. Instead they were supposed to invert the process in software and simulate what a burned disk would look like, in a way that let them adjust disk parameters rapidly until they had a readable image.)

The challenge took me a few weeks to make because "calibrating" a disk (determining the geometry of the pregroove) is incredibly sensitive.

After the CTF I tried really hard to make a repeatable calibration process with the intent of building something releasable. I even ended up measuring the details on every CD-RW and CD-R I could buy on Amazon.

But despite trying very hard, I never did make calibration patterns that were reliable enough that I felt like other people would be willing to go through the process.

It seems someone else has succeeded where I failed. Great to see!

WTF is CTF?

A capture the flag challenge (CTF) is a common cybersecurity challenge in which you are tasked to hack/reverse engineer/pwn a system or something else which falls into the category of abusing a system for different gains. There are different sites online for you to get into hacking and CTFs are just one category.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capture_the_flag_(cybersecurit...

https://ctftime.org/ctf-wtf/

Throwback to lightscribe which I haven't thought of in many years: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LightScribe

Glad I read the article, this is fascinating:

> In 2012, a LightScribe optical drive was successfully used by Maher El-Kady, a graduate of UCLA, to turn a specially prepared graphite oxide layer coated onto a DVD into graphene.[10] El-Kady and Richard Kaner, his lab professor, used an unmodified LightScribe drive. The disc was prepared by coating the disc with an aqueous solution of graphite oxide and allowing it to dry. Areas of the coating illuminated by the LightScribe laser were turned into graphene. Various shapes can be drawn, which allowed the scientist duo essentially to laser-print an ultracapacitor on graphene using consumer-grade technology.

Sun used to say “the network is the computer”.

Now you are telling me we could potentially have “the DVD is the computer”. Imagine printing not just a capacitor but a whole PCB and soldered components, putting the innards of like a Raspberry Pi on top of a specially crafted DVD that has said single-board on one side and a readable DVD surface on the opposite side! :D

there was an inkjet printer that had a special tray for CD/DVDs

the intent was to add artwork to the discs, but if you put a copper-plated board in there, printed on a circuit board, and etched away the area left behind, you'd be almost there :)

drilling holes and thru plating is my least favorite step tho

I have a LightScribe compatible external CD/DVD burner. It came with a LightScribe disc that I haven’t taken the plastic off still to this day. Since it only came with a single one I could never decide which one thing to use that one LightScribe disc for, back when I was still burning things on CD and DVD.

You didn't miss much. It took 20-30 minutes each pass, plus the extra cost for the discs.

But even if you were fine with that, it came out too light under actual lighting conditions, even after you burned it twice, which defeats the use case of making it look professionally labeled. For home use, a Sharpie beat it in every way.

Huh, that wasn't my experience. I mean, it absolutely was slow especially with sufficiently complex labels, but they generally came out fine. Granted, you absolutely couldn't just drop any arbitrary image into the LightScribe software and have it come out looking good, you'd have to mess with the contrast, but black-and-white text and line art would come out fine. And more legible than Sharpie, with my handwriting.

For a very low-sales side business (my father's hobby) the discs looked sufficiently professional to impress the people buying them — mostly his friends.

The disc shown on https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LightScribe looks normal.

I have the same issue in video games. I always end up at the end not having used my unique items because I only have 1.

i'm like that in anything vaguely RPGish, videogame/board-top/cards/whatever.

if there is a such thing as a potion or anything like it i'll horde it and never use for fear of needing it in the future, well past the last boss or the credits..

I'm kinda opposite on reason, I feel like using one means I failed to do the battle the normal way and picked the easy mode.

I've mostly healed from that affliction, at least for buyable consumables, now it is just math, if I buy X potions I won't have to go back to rest and heal, so it's more efficient to grind while spending a bit of gold earned on regen

I've noticed this a few times where I've hoarded items to use later only to find I've finished the game before that challenging "later" arrives.

For some odd reason, the specific game that comes to mind for this was Horizon:Zero Dawn PS4/5.

Conversely, I'm playing Half-Life:Blueshift right now, and I didn't try to save anything, now I've hit a couple of points where I'm out of ammo or health and can't progress without loading an older save.

I had one fun experience in Black Mesa (HL fan-remake) where I was knocked off of the edge of a "cliff" by a large enemy (no spoilers) and it auto-saved mid-air, so it reloaded me falling forever >_<.

I'm definitely the type to always be saving items "just in case" and the Half Life series is definitely one where I felt the most paranoid about that.

I played HL1 on the PS2 recently with a memory card that was really limited in space so I was only managing a single save for most of the playthrough until I soft locked myself in a room I couldn't leave using my ONLY save and had to start at least carrying a second backup save to prevent that happening again.

Half Life 2 felt like it almost made fun of me at times for building that hoarding mentality, always dumping health and ammo on me when I had already been preserving it as much as possible right before. Meanwhile the few things I would run out of it would never give any more of for entire sections.

> I played HL1 on the PS2 recently with a memory card that was really limited in space so I was only managing a single save for most of the playthrough until I soft locked myself in a room I couldn't leave using my ONLY save and had to start at least carrying a second backup save to prevent that happening again.

I get very little time to game these days, which has the benefit that I have saves usually spaced no more than about an hour apart. Sometimes a couple of hours on the weekends. There were a couple of points in HL1 where I had to go back to a previous save because I was in a bad situation, I'm playing on PC so there was no real limit on the number of saves I can keep.

I've not started HL2 yet (this time around, and it's been 20 something years since I last played it) so I can't remember what that was like.

I'm going to finish Blueshift, then go on to HL2, but I'd really like some texture and quality updates; HL2 is a real downgrade from Black Mesa. I tried it in VR but was feeling nauseous within a few minutes.

All of this is to lead up to Alyx on my Steam Frame which is just sitting there waiting until I replay these so I can remember what happened.

> Half Life 2 felt like it almost made fun of me at times for building that hoarding mentality, always dumping health and ammo on me when I had already been preserving it as much as possible right before. Meanwhile the few things I would run out of it would never give any more of for entire sections

I'll bear this in mind. I think HL1 was a little too obvious; you suddenly get a cache of rocket ammo, you know what's coming.

Oh god that was the worst. And then Trine came out.

Me but with notebooks. Not unique or interesting ones. All of them. I'm always worried about ruining the notebook by putting the wrong stuff in it so I just have an ever increasing collection of blank notebooks that I thought were definitely the one I would finally use.

I haven't worked with paper in a long time, but IIRC some notebooks I used in school had pages you could tear out, sacrificing a strip along the side, while preserving holes that'd work in a 3 ring binder. So then you could just write anything in one of these notebooks, tear it out, and put it in a 3 ring binder afterward. The binder could be more thematically organized then, separate binders by subject. A bit like opening your text editor, writing stuff down, then deciding which dir to save it to later.

Also even if your paper doesn't have the holes, you could use a punch to add them, assuming you have space on the side without writing.

Also, backtracking 5 minutes to pick up the health pack at the start of the level instead of the one right in front of me

same but brain

DiscT@2 (1), the granddaddy of them all.

This was followed up by Labelflash in 2007(2).

(1) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DiscT@2

(2) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Labelflash

I still have a DiscT@2 capable drive running (a Yamaha CRW-F1), though I haven't tried the imaging capability in... geez, 20 years.

I had one of these as well... What a trip down memory lane, thanks for sharing.

I was just thinking of those!

I used to have a label system called Neato, which provided round CD labels you could make on a printer, along with a tool to press them accurately onto the non-recording side of a CD-R. There were even transparent labels, so the resulting disk looked like a commercially produced disk.

Sadly https://www.neatolabels.com/collections/cd-dvd-labels

Aww, bummer. If money was a problem they should have just rubbed some AI on it.

Later on, when CDRW were ubiquitous you could get CDs with inkjet compatible labels that you could print direct in an inkjet printer using the bypass path (straight path for rigid materials).

I had one of these as well. It was pretty useful in the days when my HHD was 20GB and regularly filled up.

This is exactly the sort of thing the 2020's are missing. Something tactile and artsy, reminiscent of the early 2000s! Well done to the author

Also see https://github.com/arduinocelentano/cdimage from a few years ago

I've always wondered if this could be used to create 3d holograms.

Apparently there's prior art on this, but it required modified firmware and the code was lost:

Sakamoto et al. (2004). "A CD-R System for Recording Computer-Generated Holograms." https://doi.org/10.3169/itej.58.549

Me too, but I don't think the resolution is good enough, even on blu-ray.

Wow! Light Scribe on the data side!

Do they actually play?

I can't comment on this particular project, but I know that similar projects have allowed adding images to the unused portions of the disc. A given region of the disc cannot be both image and data, but the disc can contain an inner region of data and imagery in the outer unused portion.

DVD codec probably allows for a certain amount of error correction to recover from scratches, images can still look readable to humans despite a bit of noise, I wonder if there’s enough overlap there to meet in the middle and have an image that also stores data

A bit like those AI images that were also working QR codes from a while back.[1]

Would be a really interesting challenge to find the point where maximally useful data meets a maximally good image. The data goes through layers of encoding to become data on disc, so it wouldn't be easy, but we already have a one-way translation here in this tool.

[1] e.g. https://www.reddit.com/r/StableDiffusion/comments/141hg9x/co...

Even if that is possible for a pristine disc, you really do want that error recovery for discs people are actually expected to use.

It supports putting data files either at the inner or outer rim, but it's at the cost of image space. So yes it can play, but not much storage.

I bet someone will come up with breakthrough eventually that allows for both an image and a mostly readable CD.

Sounds like a mixed mode disc where it defaults as an audio CD, but has the data portion available for data.

Windows 2000 & XP discs had something like this, but on the label side.

Yeah, Windows 7 too.

https://www.geektieguy.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/Copyof...

Is anyone still making new optical drives?

Lots of new USB DVD drives are available from brands I've never heard of. But the availability of Bluray drives is so low I suspect they're only new old stock.

I'm almost certain the reason is licenses - DVDs licenses have long expired and back when they were in effect DVDs were the mainstream option, so lots of devices and machines around for them when licenses were needed and that gave momentum to DVDs. Blurays on the other hand still require licensing and they never became as mainstream as DVDs.

I can find a bunch of small businesses pressing CDs and DVDs but they rarely provide a Bluray option. I have a feeling that even after Bluray patents expire, DVDs will still outlast Blurays :-P.

You should look for Blu-ray drives instead of Bluray which does not exist /s

Back around 2007 during the red vs blue HD laser format war, the spelling was hammered into me as the incorrect spelling was tirelessly brought to one's attention. Since we're going down memory lane on shiny discs, I couldn't resist bringing this one back too

Probably. Bluray still exists, still a popular medium for selling games on PS/Xbox and to certain extent movies to people who like to watch on their high-end equipment.

Sony is discontinuing all the BD disc players,as well as famously discontinuing disc games for the playstation.

XBox is making similar moves but isn't committing 100% to the bit yet.

Sony probably hasn't been the OEM for their drives in ages. Microsoft never was. I'm sure there are still one or two OEMs who build drives.

Absolutely. And discs as well. I had an x-ray recently and asked them to give me the image so I could take it to a different clinic, and they burned it onto a CD. So I suppose optical media is sort of irreplaceable for medical applications at least.

Like floppy disks were in Japan for a long time... and fax machines in other countries.

The thing is that sometimes you just need a cheap physical medium you can give away. Sure cloud is an alternative, but it's a bad one, since it costs money to keep online. A CD or a floppy is something you record and forget. And USB sticks are much more expensive and can be a security risk.

oh, how quickly we forget the infamous autorun debacle of the CD-ROM

Autorun ran automatically because it made sense back then since there were no recordable CDs yet. It was assumed that no one would put malware onto a pressed CD, except, apparently, Sony.

Starting with, iirc, XP, Windows started prompting you whether you'd like to run the autorun.

Apparently faxing is the preferred medium of exchange in the medical field.

One would think that some sort of common EDI would have come around by now.

I suppose it has been awhile since LightScribe was a thing. People forget and reinvent so much these days it's funny.

This is modifying the data side, LightScribe uses the reverse label side

Right. So it's reinventing the thing that came before it.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DiscT@2

And I suppose the other repo that does this already

https://github.com/arduinocelentano/cdimage

I knew this was possible for years; I just couldn't find the programm.

This would be an absolute banger in 90s or early 2000!

star graph looks very inorganic

That's what happens when your project randomly blows up through a translated tweet haha

Do folks here know the data goes “into” the label through the clear plastic?

A fellow xth grader did a science project on this, and I’ll never forget it.

What do you mean by that? I don't think the laser writes data into the label usually. There is a reflective layer though, that will be damaged easily when scratching or peeling off the label.

I think they're suggesting that the "data holding" layer, is actually the label, not the plastic.

The plastic is purely for protection and rigidity, the "label" is the actual functional part of the disc.

Right!

Truly, China has overtaken the Western world in innovation.

I wonder if the disk can still hold data at the same time.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com