If men and women have meaningful differences then it makes sense to have gendered laws.
I think pandora's box is open never to be shut again on the conversation if we're the same or different.
If men and women have meaningful differences then it makes sense to have gendered laws.
I think pandora's box is open never to be shut again on the conversation if we're the same or different.
People chafe against things like DEI as arbitrary favoritism completely failing to note that yes, this policy is meant to promote equality, not to represent it. In the case of promoting female stem workers you might say it’s a policy designed to give women equal-ish access to the job market by way of giving them preferential treatment in hiring, to counteract biases of men favoring men during that process.
The ideal outcome of any policy like this is that once the systemic inequity is resolved, the policy can be retired.
It's really weird that it ever became a serious talking point!
We could attempt to argue that all groups of people have identical capabilities (IQ bell curves), and only environmental factors (lead in paint/poor early nutrition, etc) are the cause of all observed differences/life outcomes. But that would just ignore real world observations and 50+ years of failed interventions to normalize all groups in the U.S.
Also: https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/average-i... We can quibble on the accuracy of all the data, but generally we should likely take it as directionally correct.
It will be interesting to see if China maintains it lead with it's likely on going demographic collapse and how heavily the one child policy skewed abortion rates in parts of the population/pushed high degrees of educational investment.
Also likely won't matter too long now that we've begun outsourcing our thinking, battlefield decision-making, math, science and coding to LLMs. Doubt most of us will recognize what a "human" looks like in 100-200 years of genetic interventions/merging with machines/etc - should anything identifiable as a human last that long. Or some may, but they won’t be where the action is in economic/scientific terms. So no worries if noticing differences between populations conflicts with your moral belief structure. Give it time.
Anything else could be happening. But the burden of extraordinary proof for cold winters is on anybody arguing that it's a real phenomenon.
Futher: you just linked to a site based in one part on Lynn's fraudulent "IQ & The Wealth Of Nations" data sets and in another on self-reported online surveys, and then said "we could quibble on the accuracy of the data". Quibble, you say!
Why would the cold weather hypothesis be a theory that only goes back 200 hundred years as you claim? Just looked at some of the papers on the topic and it's tracking the human migration out of Africa and tracking when the first tools of various types were found and when. In more modern time the Norman invasion of France is about 1000 years ago, followed by England, not to mention the harsh conditions the Mongols were under (-40c degree winters) for about 3k years before conquering China - seems that led to a good bit of genetic spread.
Seems you're arguing that there are no differences between IQ in populations regardless of immigration patterns/conflict/harshness of the environment? If that's your claim please state it. My claim is that there are observable differences in populations of people, that are observable in the prosperity of regions and cultures, that are visible between nations and cultures, and that IQ distribution is highly likely to be root cause - or as close as we'll come to measuring the driving cause successfully. Evolutionary forces likely drove those observable differences.
It is simply an area that is taboo to research in depth because of how uncomfortable it makes folks whose morality is tied up in some form of cosmic equality/equity.
More over, I think it's imperative we study this vigorously and find truths no matter how uncomfortable that is for segments of society - particularly if we want to find interventions that work to better everyone's lot in society. Otherwise you'll spend lives and treasure to make no meaningful improvements to the conditions of people country/culture.
There aren't many Ashkenazi Jewish sprinters in the Olympics, is it so far fetched to believe that there might be more than sprinting ability differences between populations? Should these differences not be studied to better understand and improve society?
This is obviously not an area that is "taboo to research". You just don't follow the fields that research it. The website you cited in your last comment was a pretty powerful clue towards that!
When algebra was invented the Fertile Crescent was significantly wetter and cooler than it is now.
The claim is that severe winter conditions select for intelligence, not that intelligence grades continuously with average temperature!
That 1500 BC Babylon was neither a cold-weather clime nor an arid clime is evidence against the cold winter hypothesis.
(To your point about intelligence vs. progress, it's suggestive evidence, not dispositive evidence, but the amount of suggestive evidence over the course of human history makes the cold winter hypothesis pretty funny.)
For instance, empirical evidence finds that gender bias in tech hiring favors women over men [1]. So DEI ends up exacerbating the bias, not counteracting it.
DEI does not need to be selective favoritism. It could just be a policy to promote equality. It also happens that the government is the employer, and customer, of professions that has the highest grade of gender inequality (for both men and women).
I'm curious if you could describe a DEI policy that's flawed in this way and then go on to explain how you would implement it in such a way where it wouldn't be subject to the same criticism.
Gender neutral DEI policy is not hard to make, they are just unpopular. They don't give advantages to an intended demographic.
An initiative that is know to scale, is not discriminatory in its application, and is known to have a good effect in addressing gender segregation would be a mentor program. Be that an engineering office, nurses in an hospital, construction workers, garbage collectors or a research department. It is an DEI program that is know to work and generally cost effective since it increase employment retention.
This is just flat wrong. Both because the word narrative makes no sense in the way you've used it in this sentence, and because equality of outcome is specifically not what is being targeted by these policies.
I'm inclined to think you've imbibed a lot of propaganda on this subject as the use of the word "narrative" in this incorrect fashion is as strong an indicator of that as the emdash is of copying stuff from ChatGPT.
> If men and women have meaningful differences then it makes sense to have gendered laws.
This framing of the issue puts the discussion down an awkward rhetorical path that is difficult to recover from.
What if it doesn't matter whether someone looks or acts different; but it matters how society treats them and the outcomes that they face.
Black chess pieces and white chess pieces are superficially, trivially distinct. Yet, the player with the white pieces wins 52% to 56% of the time.
I'm calling it out here because it's a typical technocratic bad-faith argument that I'm personally tired of hearing.
Is "right" defined by the nature of existence or just by the ends? Some would say an outcome of hunger is unacceptable, some would say there are plenty of "wrong" (try to not make that moral meaning) behaviors which should result in hunger. (Such as refusing to work or trade value for other people's property ie food)
For example, there was an initiative in Sweden to improve diversity in the student body by giving minority demographics free bonus points during application. For any given minority the outcome would be a small but meaningful advantage compared to the majority so that over time the balance would improve and become closer to represent society as a whole. It was a very unpopular imitative, especially by the left, and later was found to be deemed discriminative. Such initiatives are only supported and approved by the legal system if they are selective.
no controversy of this in chimps.
no magical evolutionary moment when they became the same in humans.
biologists know this. sociologists start with an unfounded null assumption.
This cuts both ways: you will often see physically emasculated men get treated as if they're not men, to their detriment. Think of less-developed young men being cut from sports teams; they have the same in-built need for physical activity, competition, even some measure of practicing dominance, as larger boys. Deprivation leads to frustration and more.
You seem to be treating stereotypes as facts.
OR
Something something testosterone and estrogen levels.
Distinction is always going to be less effective than universally agreed declaration. We can declare: all human beings have equal rights.
Pandora's box is the universality aspect, which must be manifest by those agreeing to declare the nature of ones rights in respect to others rights, both for oneself and for others. This is the reason a distinction-based legal position is poor policy.
We cannot distinguish between a man and a woman if we are agreeing to the universality of their equal human rights.
The we part is the difficult part, apropos pandora's boxes. But ultimately, universality is very empowering to the individual.
That this expression has become the root of an industry of exploitation (divorce proceedings are a big circus) is clear. Rights are not a constant. They have to be expressed.
Like in vows, maybe.
I don’t even get how I am supposed to hold my partner to the same standards I would hold a close male friend/family member. If I knew a dude who freaked out and yelled/sobbed several times a month over something inane like where to get dinner I would drop them immediately. I have found just using the old adage “happy wife happy life” is most effective, but isn’t that inherently disrespectful? Like “I can’t reason with this person but if I upset them it’s gonna go poorly for me so I better let them have their way!”. The only way my relationship survives is if I have a bit of internalized misogyny and hold her to a different standard than I do myself or another man.
Conservative men rights advocates find such proposition insulting to men. It is not a manly men job.
Men in those positions are mocked by supposedly pro-male groups
> If I knew a dude who freaked out and yelled/sobbed several times a month over something inane like where to get dinner I would drop them immediately.
Why are you dating someone like that? Genuine question. I dont know ANY woman that cries that often. Not a single one.
Maybe be wise and break up.
“They claim men and women are no different apart from their environment” tends to be a claim made by those who can't cope with the singular “they” let alone anything else, who are trying to make those who disagree on such points seem ridiculous.
---------
[1] particularly in the endocrine system, though in other parts² which might also have an impact on how we react to things and our mental health more generally
[2] it isn't just emotional matters and related coping mechanisms: heart attacks often manifest differently in women, or if not that then the signs are often misdiagnosed, for instance
[3] either for talking about specific detailed differences, or for identifying people in terms of their identity & phycological makeup more generally
The status quo of "sexual liberation" doesn't do much to mitigate this difference. We no longer live in a monogamous society.
Have you ever spoken with a woman?
This is not at all the case, regardless of your anemic "relations."