Hacker News Reader

Comment by Huarache1 | Hacker News Reader

"Of course men are the villains when they hold the most power."

I agree with the statement, but not the context.

Looking at Velma, Dragon Age: Veilguard, Ghostbusters 2016, Star Wars sequels, She-Hulk, and much more, a good chunk of such Western media feels like they have some disdain for a large portion of fans who watch them.

Like a Superiority complex formed out of deeprooted insecurities of their feelings towards men.

You could argue men have reacted to this in the same way, especially in Instagram and the like.

View on HN

If you're going to use art to back up your point that society hates men, then there is a literal mountain of artwork throughout humanity that vilifies women.

Nobody should be villified for who they are born as, especially on Mainstream media. That's my point.

This is about a trend of the recent decades to reboot popular franchises with formerly male heroes and replace them with female versions (instead of, i.e. think up new female heroes).

If we're talking about where future art direction is going, then how much artwork from centuries ago exists is not relevant.

In that comment we have one example of this happening. The star wars sequels are an example of thinking up new female heroes.

I think it's gotten better? Ghost Busters: Afterlife (the movie following the 2016 one) also went back to their original cast and instead introduced Phoebe as a new protagonist.

I was noticing it most strongly with Disney. Not sure what was their strategy there, but for some period in the last few years, they seemed to go mechanically through their IP catalog and produce a life action reboot for each classic. The reboots were mostly unremarkable IMO, but they had a strange recurring pattern: Almost every one of them included one controversial change to the original setup that was guaranteed to rile up certain fans and cause drama, ostensibly in the name of DEI.

It became such a predictable occurrence that I'm honestly not sure if they really felt the need to "modernize" their classics, or if they were deliberately causing those controversies as a promotion tactic.

IMHO were cashing in on the ridiculous culture war - drama guarantees clicks -> free marketing -> more revenue.

The reboots are utter garbage even if you disregard the woke1.0 updates

Btw Disney has always been garbage and always will be. If we use that as the measuring stick for culture idk

Disney's Quality has been downhill since Pinocchio, that being said, I'm not expecting Jorge Borgesian tier quality of prose, introspection and self-awareness within the plot. I'm expecting it to be enjoyable popcorn flicks.

But i'm getting terrible movies that also preach massively. Even without the preaching, it's terrible, but preaching certainly makes it even worse than what it was due to the immense hypocrisy of a gigantic corporation asking us to do better while it absolutely does worse daily.

Yeah we need more of that. Humanity did well when women were kept in the kitchen

Surely if this is indeed a good chunk of western media you would need to reach for an example from a decade ago.

those examples you listed are really not representative of media in general - i don’t even know half of them! Most of these are fanslop anyway, utter garbage even before their woke 1.0 versions. Like ghostbusters or Star Wars sequels were never good And to my knowledge for example the ghostbusters was a major flop.

Sounds to me like you get your knickers in a twist for a huge nothingburger

Consistent releases of the machine known as Hollywood always influences (or attempts to influence) the wider Western zeitgeist.

This was true for America's soft power for years, until very recently, which happened to coincide with the #Metoo movement, and the drying up of (direct) American governmental funding.

Deriding them for quality alone misses the point i'm trying to make. This wouldn't be ok if the demographics were swapped with a more "vulnerable" one. So why should this be ok?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com