I have been slopping out games for years now. The graphics don't matter unless the gameplay does. The gameplay doesn't matter if the game is too hard or too easy.
The games that do well, like literature, survive because they touch the soul.
I've seen people turn away from interesting games because of the difficulty.
I've also seen people turn away from genuinely fun games because they didn't like the graphics though.
There's like, no challenge. Reminds me of that one Twilight Zone episode "A Nice Place To Visit" where a bank robber dies after getting shot by the popo five-o and he is greeted by a man (angel like guy) who takes him to a cool mansion or house where he fulfills everyone one of the guy's wishes: women, money, gambling, etc. etc. And he gambles all day long and never loses but after a while he gets bored and then depressed that he always wins and there's no effort and no risk, and then tells the angel dude that he wonders why he was put in Heaven and that he thinks he doesn't belong there and wants to go to the "other place" only for the angel guy to tell him he is in fact in "the other place".
Stuff that AI generates sorta feels like that. Meaningless and synthetic.
So in a sense, I don't worry about generations not necessarily having hardships like us, cause, look at us, we don't write in assembly code like other folks had to do. But on the other hand I do worry that AI is basically removing all manner of human touch and the satisfaction that comes with suffering to generate that human touch.
I suppose there will be suffering later when you want to polish things, but it will be a different, more frustrating kind of suffering. The kind where you don't know what the hell the LLM did and don't even know where to begin.
My mum liked to tell me, when she was little, she imagined having a magic wand, that she could wave and get anything she wanted. Almost immediately she realized that life would become pointless.
I'm not really sure if that's true. For starters, having too much scarcity and adversity can also make life pointless. You just can't do anything you want. Maybe there's a sweet spot somewhere in the middle.
For me the most satisfying part of projects has always been overcoming difficulty. Although I had a slightly unpleasant version of that lately, where the difficulty turned out to be a hundred times worse than I anticipated, took years instead of weeks, and by the time I finished overcoming it, AI could make a better project than mine in a matter of minutes...
There's a story I always come back to in my mind, there was a story of a man in the mountains in India, who spent 20 years carving a passage through the mountain — by hand — so that his village would have easier access to the city and the hospital.
It's a very heroic story of course, and you have to respect the effort and dedication... but surely it would have been better for all the people who needed the hospital, if he had just been given a bit of TNT instead.
the "utopia" where AI & robots will do everyone's jobs just sounds like hell to me. humans will adapt and find new challenges, either by finding things ai cannot do, or perhaps like a Butlerian Jihad. i don't think a wall-e scenario will last long.
A metaphor I like to use is somebody who's lived their entire life in an agrarian society seeing the Industrial Revolution imminently coming and trying to predict its effects. They'd be able to accurately predict 'super farms', but the relative economic value of those super farms rapidly trended towards $0 with the vacuum that the revolution created. It'll be the same thing here. The winners won't be people selling cognitive work, but the people building previously unimaginable things on top of that.
It's probably impossible to predict exactly what this means from here, in exactly the same way as somebody in our agrarian society could scarcely even begin to imagine what the Industrial Revolution would 'truly' entail. But I think a naive prediction would see a sharply increased value for stuff done in the real world, social type work, entertainment, and so forth. So one prediction would be that one big winner will be whoever can create cheap mass produced robotic shells to help bring the cognitive revolution to the real world. Even that will probably be seen as naive, but it's probably closer to the mark than expecting Amazon/Google/Anthropic/etc to end up ruling the world.
You are a god, and never have I heard anything more divine.
And yeah there's definitely a sweet spot somewhere.
It's like when good tools make your job easier that's great. But a tool that does the whole job for you is weird if that's your vocation.
I sometimes catch myself wanting to shout at the TV: Dude, just freaking use an electric saw, or buy a new wheel barrow (instead of repairing some old one found inside a brambles bush). You'd get to the goal so much easier, and could achieve all of your goals so much faster. But that's his entire deal: His goal is the process itself. He enjoys doing that kind of work. It's a bit of an epiphany. Kind of like that old Mexican fisherman story.
Its funny that the same CS saying "garbage in garbage out" seems even more true in the AI modern day.
test scores are dropping while the curriculum becomes easier as well.
Remember when shoes were invented? Our kids have such weak feet now. Truly technology is destroying their soles.
I'd say they have it better now.
Maybe I'm crazy though idk.
If everyone's having a personalized childhood I don't know if that will happen as much.
"The children now love luxury; they have bad manners, contempt for authority; they show disrespect for elders and love chatter in place of exercise. Children are now tyrants, not the servants of their households. They no longer rise when elders enter the room. They contradict their parents, chatter before company, gobble up dainties at the table, cross their legs, and tyrannize their teachers."
I heard this attributed to Aristotle, but apparently it's a fabrication. That's too bad because the quote is hilarious. Now if you'll excuse me, I have to go gobble up some dainties.