We didn't need AI for things to go well. We could all have a lot more if people were willing to collaborate and work constructively together instead of sucking rent from everything and tricking people.
It seems obvious today that following it up to the extreme, optimizing technology and reducing production costs ultimately ends up removing humans from the process.
I wonder if the founders of capitalistic economic model considered this outcome, going to chat with ai about that lol.
It means we become disposable to society
Look at how homeless people are currently treated for some ideas
> there will be no longer an incentive to value someone based on how much they contribute in terms of wealth generation
People need an incentive to value other people though. I don't know if you've noticed but "valuing other human lives" does not seem to come built in for us. History is built on humans killing other humans they didn't value, in order to enrich themselves
Until we reach true post scarcity I think most of us are in for a lot of hardship
I don't really buy this, at least not in developed countries - so many of homeless people don't even try to do anything, they chose this "lifestyle", they often ignore government and voluntaries programs society created to help them. And you can not enforce anything because we respect the free will, even when its completely enslaved by drugs and other things.
> I don't know if you've noticed but "valuing other human lives" does not seem to come built in for us.
I can actually argue that it does, even in nature among animals there are behaviours displaying kindness and value when it doesn't result in any profit. I think our (western) culture largely ignores these aspects.
> History is built on humans killing other humans they didn't value, in order to enrich themselves
Right, so maybe AI helps us overcome the enrich part, and as society we don't put that much value on being rich, this is where things become new and interesting.
Even if they took advantage of literally every single program that is available to them, would they have the kind of lives you would want for yourself?
> Right, so maybe AI helps us overcome the enrich part, and as society we don't put that much value on being rich
Maybe one day, how many of us struggle and suffer and die before that happens? Do you think that transition would happen smoothly and without large social upheaval? I'm not really convinced
The dream of AI enabling a fully automated socialist utopia might happen one day in humanity's future but I have very little confidence it will happen in my lifetime. And I would really rather the rest of my life doesn't play out during massive social upheaval
Right now while I can still earn money I prefer my conditions, because big changes didn't happen yet, eg I have to pay to get medical help, while in the future where AIs would efficiently replace doctors that would be one less reason, not needing a good location related to going to work etc etc.
> Maybe one day, how many of us struggle and suffer and die before that happens? Do you think that transition would happen smoothly and without large social upheaval?
These are complex questions for my level of understanding of society, I hope we can handle it well.
You cannot hope for a good absolutist king because good kings only exist in mythology. All you can do is design systems that structurally limit the power any one group or individual is allowed to amass over others in my view.
But what is the practical extent here? If you own unimaginable amount of wealth while most people are on lets say basic income, you can just afford anything, what do you get from abusing your power?
At any rate, your common masses on basic income are still living under illiberal conditions even if their shackles have been thoroughly padded. Liberty isn't merely the freedom from interference as neoliberal types like to claim, since ancient times it has been understood that liberty is the freedom from domination. According to the classical formulation a renter in a liberal democracy is still not at liberty because their landlord may turf them out on a whim, the wage labourer is not at liberty since they may be laid off at the whim of a board who neither know nor care to know their name, anyone whose living circumstances depend on the continued whim of even a benevolent master is not a free individual. Under this framing, the people on basic income would be profoundly unfree since their entire lot in life depends entirely on the benevolence of the oligarchs.
There is a good reason that even the Romans understood this danger even as they failed to prevent it. Republics should not suffer private princes, it is a lesson we have been failing to learn for over two millennia.
A good example of that is the Roman Republic. The elites created a system that gave land out to retiring soldiers in parcels that were large enough to make them middle class farmers but not genuinely wealthy. That let them churn out absurdly large amounts of heavy infantry that no one else could match. That made them slightly less wealthy in the short term than if they had just taken all the land for their own estates, but it made them immensely wealthy and powerful in the long-term.
They were also very welcoming to outsiders compared to their contemporaries. Conquered territory was basically fully Roman within a few generations (though still keeping many local customs).
Contrast that to Sparta where the elites held onto every ounce of power with an iron fist, keeping most people in slavery, and made it virtually impossible for anyone born outside the elite to join it. They ended withering away to practically nothing, sometimes fielding armies with only a handful of full citizens commanding it.
The early 20th century US is another good example. Fear of communism led to many elites supporting the expansion of worker's rights and the institution of a social safety net (FDR and JFK were both from very wealthy families).