Those are the three options for your mandate.
the non-government intervention option is just for Starlink to prove the market, and others can move in. SpaceX is willing to sell them the ride for a decent price, in relative terms.
Fundamentally, I am in the Camp that I fucking hate Musk, I didn't use to. But its undeniable, how influential he is in SpaceX and Starlink in particular.
I remember all the podcasts and haters shitting on him in, I think 2016, when the complete Starlink leadship was fired. We don't know all the details, but it's said that they wanted to do a whole other round of test sats and so on. Musk wanted to push harder on go live sooner. That' seems to have turned out quite well with no major issues in the first generation.
So SpaceX and Musk most certainty deserve a big reward for that. I agree that just rushing into 'its monopoly we must destroy the monopoly' isn't the right approach.
> Those are the three options for your mandate.
Those are not actually the only 3 only options. That's an incredibly narrow minded approach.
I have some idea but I'm sure there are more.
For example, what often works with infrastructure like this is open access rights. What if we can decouple the ground and sats infrastructure.
Allow anybody to build terminals for it. And then potentially eventually even have terminals that can use multiple such systems. I'm not an expert on these systems and how exactly they connect but long term I assume this would be possible. Because that's exactly what "GPS" does today, it connects to like 6 different systems. You could pay SpaceX a one-time fee for that. Or a license per terminal.
Or you could start to establish some standard for laser connectivity in space that eventually everybody can connect to a waste laser data network in space.
You can also make other rules. Like net neutrality, SpaceX isn't allowed to block certain things or do certain things.
Government could also chance its mentality to spectrum and maybe the buy to own spectrum model isn't fantastic.
That said, nationalization is on the table as well. One can make the argument that having multiple such system isn't really worth it. Having one and then giving it out in a different way isn't crazy. SpaceX could still be a transport provider.
Also less controversially, I think the 'monopoly' thing is way worse when it comes to the Ukraine. That is a situation where the government should be clear about how to handle it. We can't have Musk doing his own foreign policy.
If that is facism to you then you need to go back and read some political science.
Neither regulation nor nationalisation are 'facism'. In fact facism is well known for not nationalizing and instead forming a tight government-cooperation integration.
Social democratic and socialist regimes have done more nationalisation.
Like when my country, Switzerland, nationalised the railways 1898:
https://sbbhistoric.ch/wp-content/uploads/S-048_VARIA_338-sc...
Is this Switzerland facist?
You’re using the word “forcing” as a dogwhistle to compel nationalist sentiment. I said I won’t repeat myself so you can find the most relevant word for this type of exchange in the original comment ;)
Regarding Sweden: I particularly don’t care for the whims and opinions of Swedish law. I’m not Swedish, it’s highly irrelevant to me, sorry.
Government by definition is a monopoly on force. Everything the government does is backed by force.
> Regarding Sweden
That you don't seem to know the difference between Switzerland and Sweden suggest you don't even have a 3rd grade education so I'm gone stop commenting.
Yeah no shit. You started hating him when you learned that he voted differently than you lol
Perhaps it had more to do with, erm, you know, his history of attacking people, mistreating workers, spreading misinformation, promoting far-right conspiracy theories, misleading investors, and using his power to interfere in politics and even international conflicts ...
And that's just clearing my throat ... horse trading? disowned by his own children? comments by his ex-wives, the list is endless, actually ...
The guy's evidentially a twat.
Fool you once, shame on him, fool you 25,429 times ... shame on you.
https://www.logicalfallacies.org/argumentum-ad-populum.html
And you claim that a top professor at the Harvard School of Health and Pulitzer-winning journalists are "conspiracy types". So, no, your position is not credible.
https://hsph.harvard.edu/news/usaid-shutdown-has-led-to-hund...
https://healthjournalism.org/blog/2026/07/how-pulitzer-final...
There are 1000 credentialed scientists. 999 think X. 1 thinks Y. One cannot say that Y is true just because that scientist has qualifications.
You are welcome to your beliefs and should be free to express them, but not free from criticism of them if they are on the outer fringes.
Do you think the world spends billions on public health for shits and giggles? What do you think happens when you stop providing basic vaccinations and life-saving healthcare to tens of millions of people?
You have provided no theory or explanation that supports your alternate reality in which parasites exit the body willingly, infections manifest their own antibiotics, and contagious viruses eradicate themselves. Yet somehow, you believe this. So go ahead. Make any attempt at supporting this insane conclusion.
And second of all, I'm from a society where people don't instantly hate each other because of most of their votes.
I always assumed that Musk was a centrist liberal but with libertarian or maybe cooperatism right wing view on economics. That didn't make me hate him.
When he started to full on spiral down the alt-right pipeline, and started to re-tweet every bit right wing conspiracy nonsense, absurd lies and slander about immigrants and transe people. That's when I started to hate him.
And even more when double and tripled down.
And then even more when he literally trie to do private negotiation with Putin because he know better then everybody else trying to sell the Ukrainians down the river just so he could be the hero.
And then even more when he literally does Nazi salutes like a 14 year old edge lord and pulls the 'its just a joke' haha bullshit.
And then even more when he spends 100s of million, more then any other donner in US history, trying to literally outright buy himself political position like magic the gathering cards, as if democracy was his to simply own whenever he wanted.
If you don't hate him after this, just because 'he votes republican' then you are almost certainly also minimally a facist and morel likely a neo-nazi or so brain-warped by politics that you should seek mental help.
I hope for you its the second thing.
“Nationalize SpaceX” is a Musk-haters’ fantasy.
And Elon/SpaceX doesn’t get to decide foreign policy via Starlink, at least not since Starshield. Maybe he has influence with Trump, but not direct control of how the government does or doesn’t use Starshield.
But people act as if this was some crazy thing to nationalise infrastructure are silly. The US has less history of that then others but the exception you made are pretty fucking big. And of course other countries then the US exists.
Penn Central is bigger Starlink ever was. Yes it was failing, but it could have been sold for parts.
> And Elon/SpaceX doesn’t get to decide foreign policy via Starlink, at least not since Starshield. Maybe he has influence with Trump, but not direct control of how the government does or doesn’t use Starshield.
Pretty sure the Ukranians are using both Starshild and normal Starlink.
> Maybe he has influence with Trump
And a big reason he has influence is that he controls critical infrastructure. That will always get him a seat at the desk. Not sure why this is hard to understand.
There are milder options too such as making sure enough frequency allocations remain for competitors.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starlink_in_the_Russo-Ukrainia...
> In 2022, Elon Musk denied a Ukrainian request to extend Starlink's coverage up to Russian-occupied Crimea during a counterattack on a Crimean port; providing service would have violated US sanctions.[13] Media reports erroneously characterized it as Musk "turning off" Starlink coverage in Crimea.[14][15]
> Throughout the evening and into the night, he personally took charge of the situation. Allowing the use of Starlink for the attack, he concluded, could be a disaster for the world. So he secretly told his engineers to turn off coverage within 100 kilometers of the Crimean coast. As a result, when the Ukrainian drone subs got near the Russian fleet in Sevastopol, they lost connectivity and washed ashore harmlessly.
He then said he was "mistaken".
Does Isaacson make stuff up like "secretly asking engineers to turn it off" or was he asked to change it?
https://www.businessinsider.com/walter-isaacson-biography-el...
Also, why didn't you include the next sentence from your Wikipedia link?
> In October 2026, Starlink restricted Ukrainian access by imposing a speed limit of 160 km/h, disrupting several combat missions and preventing its use to intercept jet-powered Russian drones, in an attempt to get Ukraine to stop long-range strikes on Russia’s oil industry.[18][19][20]