Capability is one thing but a focus on the actual product, as an teleological destination that is built rather than something cobbled together as a solution to a problem about how to sell what you have generally has taken them the right way.
It's nice to have these types of niches when they make you money. But the Mac isn't profitable like the iPhone is, and probably makes less money than the iPad does if you count aftermarket service sales. The further Apple drifts from their roots as a computer manufacturer, the more the Mac starts to look like a liability to them.
Apple's Last Stand is their prosumer segment, and once that's gone I don't think their vertical integration playbook gets them anywhere further. Their bottom line is dependent on finding new ways to make B2C profitable, which has resulted in subscription services like AppleTV/Apple Music/iCloud so far.
That looks pretty healthy to me.
Note that because most enterprise software is now web based ( ie moved to the data centre as you have pointed out ) - a lot of the corporate Windows only lockin has gone - so I'm seeing a steady rise in Macs in business.
What's not healthy is the desktop market ( apple laptops outsell desktops like 10:1 ) - but that's whiles that's more marked in the Apple space, it's largely an overall market trend. ( Overall desktops are about 20% of total shipments ).
So Apple will only be in trouble in this space if the laptop ceases to become wanted - and that's all about the interface - some apps are better with keyboard and mouse/trackpad and a bigger screen. If all that goes away and we just talk to our computers then I'd argue that Apple are better placed than Lenovo to weather that one.
The proliferation of web-based enterprise software mostly stands to Windows and ChromeOS' advantage. macOS is the platform that has relied on "native" and "ecosystem" efforts that are becoming increasingly unpopular among consumers and industry pundits that don't like paying per-seat for software services. The Mac Pro used for render farms, on-prem hosting and cluster computing was depreciated completely, driving some of Apple's highest-margin customers over to Linux and Windows servers. Apple has absolutely began their Mac pivot to prosumer/B2C vending, and it's resulted in advertisements and SaaS slop invading macOS.
Lenovo will keep selling laptops because that's their product equivalent to the iPhone. Apple's equivalent to the iPhone is... well, the iPhone. If they see an opportunity to force Mac users into an iPad-esque experience, they'll take it in a heartbeat and play coy asking "what's a computer?" like the iPad advertisements. The Mac not an important product for Apple these days, the App Store is.
Totally agree that Mac servers ( they went years ago ) and Mac desktops ( and desktops in general ) are on the decline.
I just think you are basing your opinion on the past. Sure in the past, when Apple hardware was worse overall than the Wintel offering, Apple heavily relied on the Mac specific software, and your right that's less important now more than ever.
But the point here is right now, and for the last few years, Apple hardware is significantly better! And because of this in turns your argument on it's head.
I think we both agree that the landscape in terms of mix of devices may change in the future - I just think Apple is following that market, not 'forcing' Mac users into an iPad-esque experience.
And right now I think the laptop market is still pretty healthy - I can't see Apple moving away from it unless sales drop, and as I said sales are actually rising.
What I meant by "Apple's Last Stand" was referring to the Mac. Their destiny is to become "the iPhone company", and their inability to support the Mac as a competitive product has basically guaranteed that fate. The landscape of computing already changed, and when Apple was confronted with the opportunity to invest in GPGPU products, Vulkan or PCIe hardware support, they forced those customers to pound sand. That is not an optimistic outlook for their future ambitions, at least from where I'm standing. The "my way or the highway" philosophy is hemorrhaging market share.
The data says the opposite.
In the only non-phone markets that matter - laptops and tablets - Apple is doing very well - and as I said, in the laptop market it is growing market share.
It's fine not to like Apple, Apple products or the choices they have made - but you need to ground your arguments on the facts. Yep you might not be their target customer - and they may have lost you - but overall their laptop market share is growing.