What I’m saying is that not all UK law works on the basis of accusations without evidence, like the GP argued.
Take this specific example, UK civil law does say the initial communication doesn’t have to include the patent numbers. However it does go on to say that if threats are then made then that information should be disclosed
https://www.gov.uk/guidance/the-patent-act-1977/section-70b-...
If Synaptic require multiple weeks of work at $25,000 a week, to establish what patents are infringed, while also threatening to charge the developer for that time as well as further legal action, then it’s safe to assume that Synaptic didnt have enough confidence from the outset that their original claim was reasonably true.
In short, they are opening themselves up to litigation in return. But since their legal budget is vastly greater than this solo dev’s legal budget would be, they can skirt the fridges of what would be reasonable permitted communications.
BI doubt many UK judges would take favourable view with how Synaptics have handled their correspondence; if this ever were to reach the courts.
A comment that the GPs you’re defending was objecting to
However you did “all of law works that way” and I’ve proven that isn’t the case.
And a funny thing happened. In the process of proving not all law is like that, you also proved that patent law is uniquely NON-extortionist (in the UK). Like you mentioned elsewhere, Patents Act Section 70B forbids certain kinds of patent-related threats. I'm assuming there's no general law applying to all such legal threats, or else there would be no need for this one. That would imply the law permits certain kinds of lawyers to be more extortionist than others, and patent lawyer are on the lower end of the spectrum. Is that so?