I then examined where they were opening their offices in a wave of rapid expansion. Almost invariably at the most expensive areas of each city. When I questioned that to the people in charge of their location strategy, they said "that's where the young people want to live".
These were rental-heavy, 1/2 bedroom rich, ultra gentrified high cost locations. As the offices grew and the "young people" started getting married and buying property, they would have to move far away.
We see some of that effect with places like State College PA with it's growth, decent job market, a couple hours from a larger city (Pittsburgh).
I think it's a bit of everything, but if we decentralize too much, it becomes less energy efficient, and energy costs more in Europe compared to a lot of countries. If you decentralize, you need more fuel to get groceries, to go to work, to heat your home etc.
There is a good middle ground. Probably by creating more jobs and flats in cities with 50-200k inhabitants.
Cities are attractive for people because they present more opportunities: more things to do, more people to meet.
More people == more commercial opportunities, which translates to jobs.