Either graded from A-E (A being excellent, E being poor) and you can break down that score from your three character disclosure.
Either graded from A-E (A being excellent, E being poor) and you can break down that score from your three character disclosure.
I actually started toying with single letter ratings to start with, but there are some issues with it. Giving something like a single letter grade to a repo has to make judgement calls about AI, which is something I'm trying to avoid with ACR. Some people won't touch any AI code, and others are ok with it as long as someone knowledgeable reviews it, and a single score would have to pick one of those views for everyone. The idea is to give a few key points and let the reader decide what that means to them.
A single score also kind of hides what people may be looking for. For example, an A3a (an expert wrote most of the code with AI and checked every change) and C1e (very little AI code but nobody checked it) could end up with the same grade. A multi-character rating seemed to offer up more information at a glance.
If you want a single pass/fail, you can still get one by setting your own minimum for each part, like "Oversight b or better", and any rating either meets it or doesn't.