I caught Microsoft Defender uploading my unreleased software without asking
garrettstimpson.ca
garrettstimpson.ca
So basically, paranoia confirmed.
Why immediately jump to "screen by Microsoft for a more nefarious process"? It sounds like you were sloppy with your initial disabling (or more charitably, microsoft dark patterns), so you actually disabled "real time protection" or whatever, rather than everything.
So I don't know how you can call it anything but nefarious. It didn't turn itself back on in any setting panels, it claimed it was disabled and was confirmed disabled for a number of years, then suddenly comes back on in the background despite claiming to still be shut off.
How is Defender supposed to know the origin of an exe on disk?
Like any antivirus program did 30 years ago. I know, SW is hard at Microsoft but ...
No, in 1996 it's extremely likely that they did have an Internet connection, though probably a crummy dialup one.
(Or ameliorated )