I had only heard about a consensual relationship.
[0] https://www.woodsrogers.com/insights/publications/this-valen...
Do you have stats on how common these are? Is it more popular in some non US country maybe?
Good idea about stats. Please share what you find.
1. The subordinate story broke yesterday. The stock dropped 12% (not 20) and recovered half.
2. But for the spy/export control subversion, do you think a CEO would be stepping down for banging a co-worker? LOL...
*that we know of
Obviously it depends from case to case and there are certain lines that shouldn’t be crossed but otherwise consenting adults should be free to make their own decisions.
* My age, +/- 2 years.
* Comparable emotional and intellectual development.
* Same level of education.
* Earn within 10% of what I earn.
* Total net worth within 10% of mine.
* Muscular, so we're of comparable strength.
* Exact same cultural and ethnic background.
* No chronic diseases or disabilities, since I don't have any and that would be an unfair advantage.
* Read Hacker News just as pathologically frequently, so we both know when to short NVIDIA at approximately the same time.
The strength differential is why the domestic violence procedure is what it is and the financial differential is why asset division and alimony during divorce exists. You made a joke and then basically described the foundation for an equitable marriage.
There's no such thing, that's the joke.
A difference in habilities does not forcefully lead to abuse. There can also be abuse in "equitable" human relationships.
One does not imply the other.
The existence of the legal system and social norms does a decent enough job of deterring violence thus establishing a feeling of safety in both partners who can now say no without fear of harm. When the system empowers both partners to say no you can now trust the yes. You can apply the exact same logic to divorce with regards to money. And this is important because someone who feels they're in danger will play along, it will look in every way enthusiastic but won't be and their partner has no way to tell the difference.
So now we get to boss and subordinate relationships. There is no equalizing mechanism that makes the subordinate in this situation feel like they can say no. A boss can ruin their life and fairly easily make it not look like retaliation. And you wonder why workplaces' solution is forbid them with near zero tolerance. The only slack typically given is if a relationship starts at work between a boss and their report they immediately move the subordinate to a different reporting line. And CEOs don't get this slack because where would you move the subordinate?
So you're right power imbalances will always exist but you're ignoring that we actually do try to correct the very one sided imbalances and the ones that we can't we forbid. I mean when you get down to it the reason for hard forbidding adults to sleep with teenagers even in cases where the teenager is the one who wants it is because of the steep power imbalance.
These restrictions exist in most workplaces. Boss/subordinate relationships can result in extortion and bad behavior, regardless of which party starts it.
When did they discover the quid-pro-quo aspect of this particular relationship? The news is moving so fast that I must have missed that part.
You could just as easily say she did sexual favors to get a leg-up over more qualified peers and get/maintain her position.
If anything, the fact he got fired seems to imply she has all the power in their relationship being outed. I haven't seen anyone calling for her head.
Parent is oblivious to this and has already made up their mind that these policies don't exist
> The fact the he did it, and that she got promoted seals his fate as a predator in my mind.
These policies are intentionally narrowed to workplace conflicts of interest. HR doesn't want to manage morality clauses or stuff outside the workplace.
Anyway, not sure if that's the case here but it's hard to rule out entirely.
> Even if it's consensual, what happens when she decides she wants to move on from the relationship?
Then they're no longer in a relationship and still have to follow HR/company policies.
>What about her peers that didn't receive promotions while she did?
Did they follow the company policy (e.g., hiring committee recusal) or not for the promotions?
>This is why these laws exist.
Did the company policies follow employment regulations when setting and enforcing their policy?
I see your opinion. In MY opinion, this wouldn't be an issue but for the spy scandal. Now, anything that comes up (complying or not complying with policy) triggers more urgency by shareholders and the board to make change. They don't care about HR due process.
Once one person has the ability to get the other fired, ruin their career, blackball them from the industry, etc. you can't know if they actually freely consented or not. Once you have coercive control over someone how could you even know that's not why they "consented?" Even if they initiated you can't know if at some point they wanted to stop but now felt they couldn't because of fear of retaliation.
What is known now is described a conflict of interest (which is bad already for a CEO). Whether it was a harassment - investigation should show.
People in these threads are pretending that 75% of the story doesn't exist and it's just about an affair... insane.
EDIT: Is this just X infecting HN? I don't go on X so I don't know what it's like.
This one tip gets you off the hook of any company slander; just release a LLM model.
Misbehavior without consequences seems to have become more noticeable in politics within the past ten years, with mainstream news outlets reporting on insider trading and potential bribes for favors. This ethos of power over accountability seems to be having a trickle down effect on general sentiment.
It's mindboggling that you describe an apparently completely consensual affair as "sexual harassment". That's absurd.
Also, I don't think there was an "extreme power imbalance". If anything, she had far more power over him than the other way around, since he had much more to lose and she could blackmail him with making the affair public or other allegations.
What's very "Cut and Dry" is that so many of you are very obviously not paying attention to the yearly training, which isn't exactly complicated or difficult material.
Famously, Mark Hurd was fired for this, but immediately hired by Larry Ellison at Oracle because he didn;t give a shit.
Musk has done worse, yet nothing has really happened to him.
At the end of the day, I wouldn't bash everyone here too strongly when everyone who lined up early behind Hillary basically acted in the same way. (And yes, even though Bill did the act, Hillary lined up easily to defend him, much like the people you mention here)
To be fair though, a CEO having an affair with a subordinate should be seen with at least some suspicion...
The irony is so sweet here.
"Subordinate", get a grip!
When I entered the workforce not so long ago most companies didn't even have policies against it. My university didn't make a policy about it until 2012. I know a very happily married couple who got married this way (a little earlier - perhaps around 2006 or 2007). I don't think they'd be happy if I referred to their behavior as "sexual harrasment".
I think it's a good policy and it's fair they enforce it, but equating it to sexual harassment is nonsense.
Extremely rare (winning such a lawsuit). Prior to these kinds of rules becoming the norm, how often did anyone win such a lawsuit? It's a rounding error close to 0.
There are plenty of publicized cases where one party openly stated she got promotions because of her affair with a senior. No lawsuits were even filed in the ones I know.
I'm in favor of such rules precisely because it's hard to win such a suit.