NYC Council passes ban on 'surveillance pricing'
gothamist.com
gothamist.com
The part of the headline you dropped (that relies on personal data) is the new part
Example was the minimum wage law. They complied by projecting if there was enough demand for certain number of drivers on the app at any time to hit minimum wage. They boot logged in drivers from the app without warning or notice of when they'd be allowed back in, in order to reduce the supply of drivers to meet demand.
Of course the drivers remained in their cars, driving around the streets of the city, frantically trying to log back in. So in practice their pay likely went DOWN for the same amount of actual hours worked. They just weren't in-app for all those hours.
So curious how they will figure out a way to do that here. I don't want to even speculate here in case any Uber Pricing Quants are reading.
lol - amazing how often highly technical people will believe urban legends when they fit their priors.
That one in particular has not only been denied, but disproven.
[0] https://www.vice.com/en/article/uber-surge-pricing-phone-bat...
[1] https://www.wkyc.com/article/news/verify/verify-does-uber-ch...
Uber is known to intentionally offering different experience for different users at different times.
Ban facial recognition by the government on civilians and ban Flock and similar. But they aren't interested in limiting their own power.
Sliding price caps that target only specific things can work, like parking fees that scale according to the median wage of a given part of a city.
This seems to be more like the latter rather than the former. Retailers can still adjust prices before the business day is over based on immediate feedback, they're just not allowed to dig through a potential customer's device to do so or target specific individuals.
For example, if 1 kg of iron produces more value when used to make cars than when used to make hammers, car manufacturers can pay more for the iron and acquire more of it, benefiting the community because the iron is used to make something more valuable. The extra cars produced are worth more than the hammers lost.
But, the abundance of cars makes cars less valuable, while the scarcity of hammers makes them more valuable. At some point, hammer manufacturers generate the same profit per kilogram of iron as car manufacturers. It is mathematically demonstrable that, at that point, the total value of cars and hammers reaches its highest level, and iron is being used at maximum efficiency.
Socialism has nothing even close to that because socialists don't know the value of things.
For that reason, one of the main tasks of Soviet spies was to go to USA supermarkets and record the prices of everything so that those prices could be applied in the Soviet Union, so they could plan what to produce. But that didn't work because free market prices are optimal, for local conditions, which were completely different in the Soviet Union.
So your Marxist economic beliefs simply don't work at all. They had been tried on more than 100 countries and failed on all of them. The Soviet Union produced fewer cars than Argentina and was never able to produce enough food to feed itself.
Therefore, it is easily demonstrable that the free market optimizes the use of resources, while socialism cannot even begin to start.
First, value can't be measured.
Second, profit is an increase in money, not value. If I make a mud pie and lobby the government $500 to impose a $1500 subsidy on mud pies and sell it for $1400, my profit is $899. If I hypnotise people and make them want to spend $1400 on a mud pie, my profit is $1399.
Third, you cannot "demonstrate" something by merely talking about it. It has to work in the real world.
Fourth, I don't recall saying anything about Karl Marx.
You do not understand what value is: it is not absolute, but relative. If you choose to buy food instead of rats, you raise the value of food and reduce the value of rats. So "value," or price, reflects priorities.
Value does not matter as an absolute value, but relative to other things.
If you are thirsty, a bottle of water has great value to you in that situation. But if you have a million bottles of water, the value of water to you is lower. So value depends on utility and abundance: it changes with the situation.
The free market assigns resources optimally because, as the situation changes, prices also change, and the market adapts.
Your example about "lobbying the government" is false because lobbying the government is not the free market; it is socialism. Only under socialism does the government manipulate prices and impose subsidies.
Socialists are the only ones always demanding governments that alter prices and make subsidies.
So you are criticizing socialism, not the free market. The free market is free FROM THE GOVERNMENT.
The free market works in the real world: all rich and developed countries are capitalist. All socialist countries are poor and miserable.
That's the scientific, experimental proof that socialism is wrong and capitalism is right.
You are the one going against reality.
The governments of all rich and developed countries regulate their markets, alter prices and make subsidies. No modern economy is free from the government.
Both indexes show that standards of living and wages rise statistically with economic freedom, and fall with lack of economic freedom.
So you are proven wrong again by the facts.
You have no answer. You don't even know how to start because socialism has no answers.
The free market has plenty of books and theories, backed by experimental data, so it's scientific.
Socialism has absolutely nothing, because socialists believe that the value of things is equal to the cost of production, and that's absurd.
If the value of things were equal to the cost of production, then a machine that is inefficient and consumes double the energy would produce double the value and would be better, when in fact it is worse.
If the value of things were equal to the cost of production, it would not matter how you assign the resources: whatever use you make of them uses the same resources, has the same cost, and is equally valuable. Using iron to make a pile of garbage would have to have the same value as using iron to build hospitals, machines, and airplanes.
That's why, under socialism, resources are always turned into products that are less valuable than their cost, and socialism creates poverty: the more socialists work, the poorer they get.
Reality is that the value of things is INDEPENDENT of the cost of production, and the only what to know the value, is from free market prices.
With free-market prices, you can make the right choices: you try to maximize profit, so you decide to minimize costs while maximizing the value produced. Profit is the actual driver of social progress and poverty reduction, but that's exactly what socialists hate the most and try to destroy.
And that's scientifically why socialism always fails.
You just espoused a blatant falsehood yourself: you said value is independent of cost of production. Those same theories and experiments you just mentioned? They disproved it.
Also nobody mentioned socialism.
"People of the same trade seldom meet together, even for merriment and diversion, but the conversation ends in a conspiracy against the public, or in some contrivance to raise prices."
And explain why the Soviet Union and China failed miserably and killed millions of people, mostly through extreme poverty.
It should had been the opposite. Explain why your arguments are the opposite of what happens in reality.
The worse things you point about USA, the more the good things have to be to compensate, for everybody trying to get into the country, even illegally, even risking their lives to get inside.
Life under capitalism is sooo good, that everybody tries to get inside. Think of it. If the socialist discourse were right, it should be the opposite.
Trying to claim every good thing is thanks to capitalism and then ignoring every bad thing is myopic. You really think the US is the only country people want to move to? That people fleeing literal famine and persecution in other nations means nothing and they really just want more capitalism? Please.
Norway is top-ranked in the Index of Economic Freedom. Norway is literally one of the most capitalist countries on the planet. Is top 8 out of 184 countries.
https://economicfreedom.heritage.org/pages/country-pages/nor...
Socialism is so bad that socialists have to deny that socialist countries are socialist, meanwhile lying about the most capitalist countries being "socialist" to try to manufacture a lie.
Look at Google Street View in any capitalist country and compare it to any socialist country.
Socialist countries are literally trash dumps.
Nope. You stopped paying attention to usernames.
Everybody tries to escape FAMINE AND PERSECUTION in socialist countries. You defeated yourself.
Socialism ALWAYS causes famine and persecution because it doesn't work, so life is miserable, and socialism is a collection of lies (like pretending that the Nordic countries are socialist).
Socialism is hate speech, blaming innocent people for imaginary crimes. So, when socialism fails, and it always fails, it starts persecuting innocent people, whom socialists blame for the failure of the system. But even after killing everybody, socialism still doesn't work.
And compare it to a random place in Cuba.
Pick a random place in New Zealand.
And compare it to a random place in Venezuela.
Pick a random place in the Netherlands.
And compare it to a random place in Russia.
Socialists literally live in the garbage. There is trash everywhere.
Price controls don't create more supply but they reduce the percentage of buyers income taken up by the inflated item. That increases their total utility because they can buy more things for that money. It also leads to higher growth through aggregate demand, invested savings and avoiding nonlinear negative effects (small businesses shutting down because they can't pay their bills).
Should a woman with cancer pay more for a headscarf because she’s likely to need it more than a woman looking for a fashion accessory?