EU Digital Identity Wallet rollout: every EU state on one board
myid.ie
myid.ie
For all the talk about digital sovereignty, EU still builds the fundamental element of EU citizenship, the digital ID, on American companies. Baffling.
But it's obvious that nobody really cares about it after all. For instance, Germany's own official EUDI wallet for Android explicitly requires Google Play Integrity
https://bmi.usercontent.opencode.de/eudi-wallet/wallet-devel...
That's not remotely obvious.
The push for digital sovereignty is only a few months old. Governments work on timescales of years—or even decades.
It's certainly true that it would be good if they could be a bit more responsive, particularly in this fast-paced digital age. But demanding them to be doing that already, today, is just not living in the real world.
I mean I wouldn't really be surprised if you were right, but I also want to give them the benefit of the doubt for now.
https://bmi.usercontent.opencode.de/eudi-wallet/wallet-devel...
Edit: apparently the requirement was dropped in a later version
Your two goals are fundamentally at odds with each other: cheap Chinese solar panels and EVs are the only realistic route to energy independence.
That many of the EU car manufacturers bet hard against the EV transition, is pretty much a bed of their own making.
It can't survive honest competition, let alone one that also benefits from lower costs
You mean about the 3.5 wars Europe is directly involved in? Up from 2 three years ago.
Ukraine - Russia
Russia - Black Sea EU member states (esp. Bulgaria, but also Greece)
Turkey - Greece
Russia - Georgia (kind of)
How’s that a war?
Cyprus’ ongoing occupation since the 1974 invasion is, of course, another thing (habitually not raised in either the UN or the EU), though Cyprus is a sovereign state with Greece as only an inert guarantor nation.
What's more - you won't be limited to using your national wallet - you would be able to use whichever implementation works for you (so, for example Duch one).
Alas: yes, UE should push harder to avoid google/apple :/
Edit: sorry, there is a possibility there is a case of bad communication. A comment nearby (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50486125) mentions the open specs could allow for the non-requirement of Google, Apple and the likes. I may have leant on thinking that the situation could be similar to that of age verification - for which the EU built open software for ZKP, but it is said to require Google or Apple or the likes.
Unfortunately not true. You can verify other nations IDs but you can only bind your ID to the eID wallet of the nation you are a citizen of.
https://www.gov.pl/attachment/735d96d3-8d85-492c-8d00-0a80c2...
The idea is that every person will have the option to use a wallet. For businesses of a certain size or type (those involved in strongly authenticating their customers, or very large platforms with more than 45M EU users) have to accept it by the end of 2027.
More details on the wallet here: https://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/policies/eudi-wallet/
We do not associate with lowly lunatics that believe normal a demand to have google or apple accounts.
And the rest of the population will effectively be bullied into also using it because companies/service-providers make using alternative methods much harder to use, because they are more expensive.
It's unfortunately predictable how this will play out.
What am I missing?
Or are you talking about non-electronic means of authentication, like presenting a passport or driver's license?
Yes, I think that would be a more appropriate comparison. Alternatives are very expensive and very hard to implement in-house
This is about government-issued credentials. When you provide a digital service in the EU where that service is required to determine the age of a user then the EU wallet is able to prove that the user is above a certain age. Or if you actually need to verify the legal identity of a user, then the EU wallet will be able to provide that identity to you. It is as official as it can get.
If you want to use your own age-verification or id-verification, then you need to rely on face scanning and other creepy stuff. The EU wallet is better in that regard, but it's existence will also mean that the EU and national governments will push harder for people to be identified online and offline. Using the internet anonymously will get a lot harder.
And when you lost your phone say bye to your life.
https://x.com/aniltalwar2/status/2113962947760590969?a=c-N4S...
So, apart from the fact that it is broken in its design.
And: you mean the USA, still that entity that decides who has a working USA telephone or not? When you are "flagged", electronic devices controlled by firms controlled by them stop working?
Not to mention the huge centralization that is being caused by cloud tech. Centralization creates single point of failures and network effects.
Harmonization of digital IDs is a good thing. It makes cross-border business easier and more secure. Integration of European markets is the whole point of the EU.
Need a bank account? A phone number? To have your car licence renewed? You’ll need it.
Edit: just noticed everyone has its own name for it? How do they envision this when traveling? Every officer needs to know the 25 different versions of this? why can't it be one app for Europe?
> Q4 2028. MIRRI plan item: implement EUDI wallet (scope unclear).
> 41 days to the EU deadline
Classic.
I get the impression the issue is more to do with the top down edict, compared to eg talking to each country and understanding their border patrol situation and offering to improve that first with resources. It came off the back of a turbulent period where border patrol strikes during COVID and the situation was just about stabilising. Pretty bad timing imo
Border security is controlled by each member state and you can't just ignore that fact and pass some EU wide harmonised change and just hope for the best
On the one hand I understand that each country has sovereign interest but in this world EU not federating and working closely will not end well :/
Very convenient to handle government matters without going to an office