Minnesota guitarist's "palmfrets" invention strikes a new chord
echopress.com
echopress.com
I was much more interested once I saw the actual website.
Long story short, it's basically a fret at the bridge end of the guitar, so using it will bring the 'root' note of the bass strings up a semitone or few.
I can see this being pretty useful for drones when fingerpicking. Though combining this with normal frets on the top string will necessarily be inaccurate because it shortens the string length, so the normal frets will be slightly misplaced.
This is a novel but slightly peculiar take on this problem. But there are lots of other things, right?
Listing for others since I suspect you know: all of this scheming about live-manipulating the basic tuning of an electric guitar dates back to the Parsons-White stringbender (and arguably further, since that was a way to get pedal steel sounds), which has led to stuff like the Duesenberg Multibender, the really extraordinary MayTrem (which keeps all strings in relative tune as the pitch is bent), the amazing Hipshot Doubleshot which lets you tune a guitar or dobro in two separate open tunings and switch between them instantaneously with a lever, etc.
Ed Gerhard added single-string frets to the bass side of his weissenborn (acoustic lap steel) that he can play with the fingers behind his slide or (incredibly) with his thumb.
All of these things are sort of fiddling at the edge of the question of a musical instrument, which is: should you confound their constraints or work within them? It's a bit like the thing about whether a dulcimer should be diatonic, whether you should add just the frets you need, whether it should be chromatic, whether it should have removable frets, etc. etc.
As a sort of hobbyist lap steel player I find all these things fascinating, but I think the ultimate question is — where do you draw the line? There are lots of things I can't play on a six-string lap steel, but should I change the instrument so I can, or should I accept the role the instrument plays, and play the things I can?
Another way to look at it is: why is the Harpejji niche? Why isn't everyone playing the Linnstrument? Why don't all pianists play the ROLI Seaboard?
I feel like this is no different than asking “what style of music should I play?”
The answer is whatever you are drawn to as an artist. What interests you more?
I hope some people work within the constraints of an instrument, and some people change the instrument. I love that there are people who make music with household items, and I love people who faithfully play instruments unchanged in design for thousands of years.
All of the options provide plenty of outlets for creativity, and I love that there are people who want to explore different ones, and share the results with the rest of us. Sometimes one of those modifications invents a new instrument that captures the heart of millions and will proliferate for decades, and sometimes someone finds a new way to play an old instrument that opens the eyes of everyone to the possibilities that were always there.
Absolutely — the pedal steel is the obvious example. The entire notion of the upward country pedal steel guitar bend is actually a side-effect of the continuous behaviour of a pitch shifting mechanism that the original designer did not design it for, which has now evolved to create an entire genre.
I think as a musician one should maybe focus on playing instruments more than being dependent on products, but perhaps the balance is shifting more towards customisation than ever before.
This is one reason why some musicians (guitarists cough) collect multiple instruments. A telecaster makes you play differently than a les paul.
For example it's not difficult to see with this thing how you can end up with arrangements that can only be played on this one modified instrument (which means as a gigging musician you probably need two of them!)
But also you have to spend the time developing the technique to use this thing, which might have impacts on your technique elsewhere.
The Duesenberg Multibender is a great example of this. It's a configurable bridge where separate levers can be configured to bend (usually bend up but with a hefty return spring they can be made to bend down) individual strings by differing amounts, which lets you can achieve voicings that sound like pedal steel instruments. (It's really cool.)
So that is possibly good if you are a pedal steel player but you want a portable lap instrument that has some of those bends for the only couple of pieces where they are needed, or you are a guitarist who has to play a couple of pieces that have pedal-steel bends in them and you don't want to buy a pedal steel.
But it has a cost: configuring the multibender takes time and the levers can only be used with the intervals they were configured for — indeed, if you configure the levers to bend strings down, you are possibly stuck in a single tuning.
It also changes the way musicians play; it's clear that compositions get written around the multibender. So it is, at that point, a somewhat different instrument to learn to really use, which takes time.
There are other ways to approximate some of the bends these levers can do — you can bend the string behind the bar with your finger, you can combine that with sliding the bar up a fret for a shifted pair of notes that match the typical bends (albeit without easy access to unshifted strings), or you can slant the bar, which has its own classic tone. These also need learning, and they have their own limitations (there's kind of only one lap steel capo that can survive string bends and return to tuning)
So for a player, the decision to use, or not use, these extra facilities is a meaningful decision in terms of how they want to sound, how much time they want to spend learning one technique over another, whether they want to compose around those facilities, etc.
(FWIW I would love one and could build a lap steel around one, but I have deliberately chosen to focus my learning attention and playing style on other techniques first)
It's pretty much the same with guitars — a lot of players decide early on that they are going to be fixed-bridge players or whammy bar players. They become quite different instrumentalists as a result.
Oh, no, not at all. I just feel that sometimes eliminating constraints is not the right choice; there's sort of a tension between freedom and focus/clarity etc.
ETA: though on further thought, the question of their instrumenthood is in there at some level, I must concede. But it is quite a complex notion.
e.g. is a fully chromatic mountain dulcimer still really a mountain dulcimer? To what extent is an instrument indivisible from its canon/repertoire?
Certain classic pieces of folk music may never have evolved if the early instrument had more freedom to fret more notes, because an entire style of playing the dulcimer (the "noter" style where you fret with a small stick) really is rather interwoven with the diatonic layout.
Like I say — there's no hard answer but I think this is a question musicians often grapple with as they develop their talent more deeply. In the same way that a lot of guitarists at the top of their ability abandon a lot of the anciliary kit (effects pedals, particular instruments) and strip back.
In the AI era I spend quite a lot of time thinking about creativity and constraints, but it has always been fascinating to me.
Isn't music better for the fact that every artist can draw their own line?
> Why isn't everyone playing the Linnstrument?
Counterargument: does someone play the Linnstrument? Do they make good music with it?
I am not at all making the argument that it isn't.
Rather I am trying to get at the idea that the "revolutionises the guitar" coverage framing that accompanies developments like this usually elides questions about musicality.
> Counterargument: does someone play the Linnstrument? Do they make good music with it?
I have never actually heard such a player myself.
The inventor's site is much more reasonable (while still, IMO, marketing the product effectively): "A New Way to Play Guitar."
Invent what you are inspired to invent.
Pedal steel is quite a diverse thing because it can be used quite obviously, or it can be used for sort of subtle sliding, stringy swell accompaniments.
Dire Straits' "On Every Street" is a good example — there's a fair amount of quite subtle pedal steel accompaniment work on the title track, "Calling Elvis" (amazing music video), "Fade To Black".
It's more obviously noticeable (comes to the front a bit more) on "The Bug".
Probably the most deliberate use of it I can think of is "Emmylou" by First Aid Kit.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y3TzP-o4vhs
But there's some on "Wolf" — great example from Glastonbury where the lap steel is quite rock-ish:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NXNHEXaKkzw
Chris Funk of The Decemberists plays pedal steel, there's a bit on The King Is Dead. "Dear Avery", for example (heartbreakingly lovely song):
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yeHhV79BCU4
Rise To Me:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mOH3mIo378A
There's also some on The Hazards Of Love, e.g. on "Isn't It A Lovely Night":
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X0Z2lZgpqKc
Craig Finn (The Hold Steady) did his solo project stuff with a great pedal steel player:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J8QBpfCSlLE
Then there's Robert Randolph, who plays in a sort of extended, rock/blues "sacred steel" style that comes from the fascinating place lap steel has in Black gospel music:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q5Dgnf824zk
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XBpViKFhrUg
Funnily enough "Sleep Walk", the song people most associate with the pedal steel, which is in aidenn0's list, was originally not a pedal steel song — it's a console steel song (twin neck, on a sort of standing table, but no levers or pedals, just bar slants for bends).
Kinda like a B or G bender, but in the opposite direction.
Vocals are also "continuous" by your reasoning, yet most notes are sung in a "discrete" way.
A precise whammy bar technique can be accurate in pitch (arguably more accurate than frets due to their fixed equal temperament intonation) and you get the added bonus of no fret noise.
Fretless guitar necks exist for similar reasons. I'm actually now curious if there exists a guitar with a fretless neck that runs the full length of the string from nut to bridge.
so this is solving the fact that using a guitar pick forces you not to use your thumb
But maybe there’s a stretch I don’t know about, I’m certainly far from an expert.
A guitar has a lot of duplicated notes. The lowest 5 notes of the low E string are unique and the highest 5 of the high E for a guitar in standard tuning.
Standard tuning is EADGBe. Every fret is a half tone. So on the low E string it goes, from open E->F->F#/Gb->G->G#/Ab->A. That A is the same A as the second open string. This is how guitars are tuned to themselves, you can play the fifth fret on most strings to find out what the next string should sound like. The exception is the B which is tuned to the fourth.
It's a bit by design, you have access to a full scale within reach of your hand, no matter where your hand is.
And this really only extends the higher range. So on the high e, instead of 5 unique notes, you'll have 5 + whatever the palmfrets give you.
Now. If it jumped you an entire octave, that could possibly be cool. Basically replace an entire pedal with a bit of hardware on your bridge.
I was going to say it's a major third, but then realized you meant fourth fret.
> And this really only extends the higher range.
No, the palm frets are only under the bass strings. So what it does is allow you to play first position bass string notes at the same time as higher position treble string notes. It extends the possible chord voicings, not the whole instrument range.
in that way, i find piano still the main multi-string instrument where its technique is genre-agnostic.
random stuff on a friday fwiw.
Especially doesnt bring much that couldn't be achieved with an alternate tuning.
Nothing against it, it just seems a pretty contrived invention.
Doesn't down-tuning and then using one of these accomplish that?
Not to discredit the invention, it's very cool indeed.
(And only the low (top) three strings?)
that's not the fault of the instrument, that's your fault.
I think someone like Mike Doors or Justin Johnson who arrange vocal lines for guitar might enjoy this, but I'm going to call that niche
A simpler solution is probably using a crossover or synth-pickup so you can split the bass notes to a pitch-shift pedal.
- Muscle memory and get decoupled from pitch. Super confusing for people with absolute pitch.
- concern about developing wrist/tendon/muscle problems
- I prefer to use a patent free instrument instead.
Cool to see people experimenting with guitars though!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=La-QiWzwgOM
Leo Kottke, Doc Watson, and Chet Atkins playing Last Steam Engine Train together.
Really having a hard time seeing any major manufacturer licensing the design and using it on any of their instruments.
But one could also do this more easily with a tremolo bridge.
As a beginner player, this isn't worth worrying about, IMO. It might unlock some interesting composition options for someone writing a song for themselves... Normally, you have a bassist playing those parts for you, though.
Because of the way intonation works in string instruments (e.g. by fine-tuning the saddle of the bridge on electric guitars/basses), I think that you'd be able to have this set up to work well in a few playing positions, but just as the frets get smaller as you go higher up the neck (because of the way pitch works on a shortened string) I'd expect the intonation to get out of whack in other spots on the neck.
> “One of the basic principles in inventing it has been: if it interferes with the normal way that you would play the guitar, it’s no good,” he said.
... but then removes several top frets from the neck, along with the fretboard, likely to have a strumming area for when the right hand is palm fretting.
I predict that hardly anyone else who installs the palm muting bridge will take a chunk out of their neck; that would be a deal breaker for most guitarists.
This will also absolutely interfere with palm muting, which is a big part of the normal way some people play guitar. Palm mute a little too hard and you suddenly get a clear, fretted note.
If you throw in playing accompaniment simultaneously you would able to emulate what a second year classical guitar player can do in his sleep!
However, I absolutely appreciate anyone trying out new things. So props to him.