The biggest problem seems to have been that word got out about it outside the MIT community, so that they were getting many calls from non-MIT people. But, their policy was to try to help anyone they could: http://tech.mit.edu/V130/N43/nightline.html
Maybe it would have been better to change the policy than to scrap the whole service.
(BTW I was one of the first Nightline staffers back in 1978.)