Elephants found to be increasingly isolated leading to fractured social networks
today.ucsd.edu
today.ucsd.edu
> "We see individual elephants leaving and possibly dying at accelerating rates, but new individuals are not coming into the population,” said Madsen. “With fewer individuals in the population, those who are left will naturally have fewer relationships. However, the remaining elephants are also changing their relationships with each other."
In my opinion "dying at accelerating rates" is the/a key takeaway. Notably climate change doesn't seem to be explicitly mentioned and hate to see poaching be a direct cause:
> Many elephant populations are already impacted through deaths resulting from poaching and conflicts with humans. Other contributing factors may be disruptions in habitat connectivity and less food available...
Other comments mention other intelligent and social species and this reminds me of Puget Sound Southern resident killer whales [0] and their decrease in food availability and offspring viability.
[0]: https://www.nature.org/en-us/about-us/where-we-work/united-s...
If it'd be my study, I'd also avoid mentioning climate-change explicitly.
With the (US-governments') move from mere verbal denial of climate change to institutional and policy-level skepticism of everything and everyone just using the term, it could cause the whole paper to be dismissed in discussions of some circles...
(With the assumption that climate change is one of the causes.)
It's more about getting the message across without the risk of being flat-out rejected immediately just because of some "trigger words".
First, is that places where elephants live are facing increasing pressure from the outside due to human settlement. National parks established decades ago or longer have borders which face ever-increasing human populations right on them. Human-wildlife conflict and elephants raiding crops farmed right next to parks are incredibly commonplace.
Second, that national parks established decades ago in most places were not designed for wildlife corridors to connect the parks. The concept of a way for elephants to walk 100km or 200km to another park is a relatively new notion. So, already, roads, cities, railroads, etc. prevent long-range migration, if for no other reason than the landscape and water sources needed for those migrations are also great spots for people to get water and establish a town.
Third, that poaching has forced elephants to change their own patterns to consolidate. They are increasingly isolated because they now feel they need to form super-herds of 50-100 individuals just to survive in places lacking proper wildlife law enforcement. So the elephants themselves see more danger in leaving the herd than staying put, which obviously creates a genetic diversity issue, among other problems.
These are all very recent issues, maybe the last 50 years in some ways, but changes in behavior like super herds are maybe the last 10-15 years in certain areas.
Dying at accelerated rates could have a number of factors, including poaching, obviously, but also stress from being in areas where poaching happens frequently drives behavior changes that might not lead to long life spans. There could also (just a guess) that after CITES was established in the 1970s to limit the ivory trade, there might have been a relative population boom. Elephants have long life expectancy, and so you have the competing incentives of older elephants with longer tusks being poached more, competing for food more, and older elephants are cantankerous. If they get into a village to eat crops, they might be shot to prevent human death, or (as I've seen happen) might each a whole field of something recently sprayed with pesticide, which can and does kill elephants.
First off, let's recall that for generations elephants were hunted for ivory by the West to make piano keys and billiard balls, among other things. So their populations were artificially low prior to vaccination campaigns.
Pressures from poaching and the difficulty of getting tourism dollars to local communities so they value the elephants are a large parts of the problem that have nothing to do with populations one way or another.
The majority of trade routes and planning in Africa are driven by natural resource extraction, not by population alone. Roads and rail largely focus on trade, and very often populations shift to either where they can find land to farm, or jobs. Encroachment on parks isn't because the rest of the country is full, it's because it's near enough to where people already life, and demand for food from towns that support tourism economies leads to the logical step of growing food near those parks. Would you really fly or truck tomatoes across Kenya or Zambia when they can be grown 2km from where they'll end up?
Enforcement of wildlife policies, and wildlife corridors that have been established usually falls to woefully under-resourced wildlife law enforcement officers that have a tough time keeping up with the poachers on patrols of hundreds of square kilometers a day. By the time a few families move beyond an imaginary line on a map, they might have been farming for months or years.
I don't think there's a wild elephant population boom in Asia, is it?
> local communities
Those local communities need a lot more than Westerners' tourism money to survive, they need roads, they need factories, they need to exploit their environment, i.e. the same thing that the West did during its development.
> Would you really fly or truck tomatoes across Kenya or Zambia when they can be grown 2km from where they'll end up?
This is making my point, of course that more people means less wildlife habitat.
> Enforcement of wildlife policies,
One cannot create a zoo out of an entire country for the benefit of the Westerners alone, the local population needs to be able to grow their tomatoes wherever they damn want.
No. Because I meant humans, not elephants.
>One cannot create a zoo out of an entire country for the benefit of the Westerners alone,
It's also a question of healthy landscapes and environments. You want all these roads and factories, while deforestation is already at near crisis levels. Water issues are common in a lot of places where forests have been felled to make way for farms - either for local foods or products for export like coffee, bananas, or flowers - as trees and healthy soils allow for slower absorption of rain water. Which means you get problems like soil erosion, flooding followed by drought, and biodiversity loss. Drought being a pretty significant problem, last I checked.
A balance that preserves ecosystems and allows for sensible development is needed, not just ad hoc or corruption based planning for the sake of "Factories Everywhere!" Production of what should happen in those factories, anyway? Factories often require fairly large pool of semi-skilled labor, and we're talking about rural villages.
It just seems like you have a fundamental misunderstanding of everything to do with an entire continent of our planet, if not most rural settings. Which isn't uncommon for Westerners, sure, but simply having boilerplate opinions tied to 20th century economic models doesn't make them somehow correct. Tell a Finn or an Aussie or Costa Rican how their rural areas should be littered with factories and see how well that idea goes over. I doubt you'll get much traction on the ground with people living real life.
North Carolina Zoo has been involved in a program to radio collar elephants to track the herds. https://www.nczoo.org/saving-wildlife/conservation/internati...
One of my family members has been involved in this program since the 1990's. They try to anesthetize the matriarch and attach a gigantic collar while the elephan is knocked out. The anesthesia is fatal to the elephant without properly timed reversal agents. You can imagine what that means with a protective herd nearby.
The website mentioned above is obviously marketing copy from the zoo, but the program is impressive and has collected incredible data over the years. My favorite reality check to the marketing copy. One of the other articles from nczoo tells the narrative: "As we move through the forest, conscious of every foot fall, I notice the tracker suddenly throws up his hand, indicating to the team that we need to stop moving." Except the tracker actually drives -- and I'm not making this up -- a Harley Davidson.
Ultimately the sad truth is elephants need a lot of space and there is less and less available in the format they need as time goes on.
PS: The article addresses this
> Many elephant populations are already impacted through deaths resulting from poaching and conflicts with humans. Other contributing factors may be disruptions in habitat connectivity and less food available for the elephants as ecological conditions change across the 119-square-mile park and surroundings.
94% of non-human mammal biomass is livestock.
Wanna help the elephants? Eat no meat, no dairy, no eggs, no fish. It's easy as that.
(I think it just wanted to eat from the tree next to the tent)
Education, jobs, desire for better living conditions did the damage for humans. Families became workers of the economies and were flung far apart.
For elephants, their distress is probably a direct result of their need for social grouping. A wild cat wouldn't have been affected by the lack of social groups.
(like bees?)
Which one was that?
Bit of an escapist fantasy, though.
Not saying these are all likely, but especially the latter ones might play a small role.
E.g. polar bears and other predators have way higher retinol accumulations in their liver these days than 50 years ago, so apparently something is changing their metabolism.
People putting a wifi router into their homes is even more recent than phone towers. Households I know only have wifi since the 2010s.
The signal travels much farther, of course, but the electromagnetic radiation past these is negligible.
People did not have radio senders in their home, they only had receivers. But your mobile phone, wifi routers and Bluetooth headsets also are senders. Yes, many hobbyists had a radio set at home, but the antenna was usually mounted on the roof.
Bluetooth, Wifi and cellular are all bidirectional, but radio is not. I assumed that's why radio doesn't make the needle move on the receiving device.
Tuskbook?
> Maybe pivot to doordash for lions?
Rate your delivery driver on the score from "Too thin, won't eat again" to "Nice and juicy".
Hat tip to the elephants for not being sociopaths like the Orca. Or otters.
Maybe the elephants and octopus should form a brilliant animals but not sociopaths club.
[1] - https://www.bbcearth.com/news/teenage-elephants-need-a-fathe...