https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2025/dec/28/nvidia-in...
https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2025/dec/28/nvidia-in...
A different question might be, will these companies grow over the new few years?
If I give you 10 Million GPU in exchange for 25% of the company and the company goes bust or has negative growth (and thus is forced to sell assets), effectively I just put 10M GPUs on the market with a huge discount.
At a grand enough scale, this undermines the GPU marker and one could argue that Nvidia has been doing this on a massive scale.
Yes, they are literally doing exactly that. Noting that they aren't truly "buyers" so much as "gift recipients" (in exchange for ownership stake, but the value of their remaining ownership also goes up if these gifts generate sufficient hype for investors to invest more). GPU production is outstripping datacenter capacity.
> But presumably those gpus are being actually used by those companies?
But, even if they were all being used, this wouldn't mean much. The central point is: suppose Nvidia has produced 10 million[1] datacenter-class GPUs during the LLM bubble. Nobody can afford to, or is willing to, buy 10 million datacenter-class GPUs at their list price because the economics don't work out. But if they gift 10 million GPUs for stock, and frame it like they sold the GPUs (a framing that is effective -- although this has been an open secret, this is being reported like news by the WSJ, and to the majority of their readers, it is news), it makes Nvidia GPUs appear to be extremely desirable. Even though, logically, an item that you have to give away because it's not economically worth its market price is the exact opposite. The fact that you can use goods that you've effectively been given for free does not increase the actual economic value of those goods.
It's pertinent to note this scheme works only as long as the hype lasts. If Nvidia gives away millions of GPUs in exchange for stake in LLM startups, and the LLM startups go bust, Nvidia is then billions of dollars in the hole.
[1] (hypothetical number, it's vaguely around this order of magnitude)
https://www.datacenterdynamics.com/en/news/microsoft-has-ai-...
> Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella has said the company has AI GPUs sitting idle because it doesn’t have enough power to install them
https://www.businessinsider.com/amazon-nvidia-ai-gpu-data-ce...
> Some AWS sites had room for more racks but not enough available power to turn them on
> At least one AWS team did not have "a clear forecasted path" for getting the incoming racks into data centers at the time
There is a fundamental difference from being able to profit on running some number of GPUs, and being able to profit from running 1 million GPUs. We do not have a business case for 1 million GPUs. Our startup's premise is that there are economically viable niches to use LLMs as tools, which is in stark contrast to OpenAI and Anthropic who are at least publicly selling the idea that LLMs are a form of genuine intelligence that will replace all human labor if you just give them another $10 billion dollars, and then another $10 billion dollars, and then another $10 billion dollars, .....
The bubble popping will actually make business cases for GPUs much more common to come by, when businesses can acquire them for closer to their cost of production rather than at the insane markups Nvidia currently lists them for. But that won't do Nvidia much good, because Nvidia's valuation is predicated on being able to "sell" as many GPUs as they can produce at a 10x markup over the cost of production - even if much of what is being "sold" is really being given away for equity in businesses that are not financially viable.
Is this a hypothetical gap or do you have actual numbers to back this up?
(Consumer sub prices were used for illustrative purposes but this obviously applies to token and enterprise spending as well. Although they're being a little loose due to FOMO, enterprises will not sign blank checks forever if the promised "replace all human labor" does not materialise)
Also, it goes without saying that a GPU that can not even be powered on for lack of power capacity is not being used profitably, at any price point. It could not be more apparent there is an oversupply relative to its current market price, which is a direct result of Nvidia giving away boatloads of GPUs for stakes in unprofitable companies.
OpenAI just seems like a black hole for money.
I think what you are describing is the sociological/ecological function of a bubble. We pull an unreasonable amount of demand forward, someone else pays for it and when the bubble implodes the good companies that survive the stress test get a free lunch.
Best of luck at the start up. That all sounds right to me. Real intelligence is specialized and ecological. The grand irony to me is that I would love to be an organism that can walk the way I do but also be able to fly like a bird and swim like a shark.
The problem is that organism would be massively too expensive to survive.
Agree with the rest of this though. This whole idea that Nvidia is likely to get much of a normal return from their vendor financing strikes me as tenuous, and what they really are getting is the creation of the perception of scarcity.
One day soon, the notion that GPU scarcity is a proxy for AI demand will finally lose its currency and I think that will be the start of the reckoning.
We are so use to the digital world and the efficiency of electronic markets that it is hard to think of physical constraints in the real world.
That isn't the issue - it's that building brand new datacentres + the power generation to run them takes a massive amount of time/permitting/money, and by the time those datacentres actually come online, you can be sure that the price pressure on inference will be sharply negative.
Nothing new, nobody pays a car cash anymore
there is plenty of electricity in china
If energy wasn't cheap, you wouldn't see people driving large vanity SUVs around in the least economic way possible.
It also requires major infrastructure to deliver that energy, which takes money and time to build, as do the datacenters.
Around 0.05-0.15% of the world population own such large SUVs.
While your datacenter is not built, guess where the AI chips are? That's correct. In boxes.
Are you sure about that? Might just as well be in Excel sheets only...
[1]https://www.techspot.com/news/114315-dark-gpus-amazon-show-l...
(AWS could have $20B of unused GPUs at this point — it's widely reported that there was at least $5B in August, with up to $3B more arriving each month)
https://www.businessinsider.com/amazon-nvidia-ai-gpu-data-ce...
We know that Satya Nadella has been open about how one of his big problems (as a CEO) is that he has bought GPUs he cannot plug in anywhere.
https://www.tomshardware.com/tech-industry/artificial-intell...
So 50%? Who knows. Seems a particularly large figure. But if AWS and Microsoft can't plug them all in, why assume anyone else can? What if it's as much as 20%?
The clear indication is that cold/dark GPUs delivered to major customers, GPUs that Nvidia has sold but still has on its shelves (buy and hold), and GPUs that Nvidia has sold, leased back from customers and may or may not have plugged into their own cloud, together represent a large enough proportion of sales to have meaningfully pushed up the prices of GPUs and caused scarcity that is somewhat artificial.
If you take the scarcity of GPUs to be a solid proxy for assessing compute demand — or even for the sales of GPUs to be a solid proxy — then you are making a dangerous bet, IMO.
Exactly whether this is just misallocation or an absolute scandal of channel stuffing remains to be seen.
Can it?
Step 2: still have money even though the financial bubble popped
Step 3: just buy them normally, at market prices
Nvidia is likely not going to surge back to $240 soon. It might go lower actually. Skeletons are still falling out of closets. Huang may have been the tech founder's tech founder, but he kept some pretty nasty company in recent years and, as we're now finding out, got both himself and his company into shady territory. As it turns out, ethics are not just for aesthetics.
Is Nvidia slowing down for a year or two bad for AI as a technology? Probably not. Nvidia could find a leader that will return them to top form, or another company could take advantage of the situation to catch up and surge past. A lot of AI researchers have been calling for a pause or, at the very least, a slow-down. This might be just what was needed.
However, given Nvidia's utterly unique position as both hardware supplier and bank for the data centre build-out, what will the impact be on the rest of the AI sector? The market is going to have to price in a weaker and slower build-out as well as a loss of trust in Nvidia. That's clear downwards pressure. Is it a blip, or are we now past the peak?
As you say, if Nvidia is chastened enough to slow its banking endeavours and that lets air out of the bubble in a progressive rather than dramatic way, that’s probably better for everyone (except OpenAI, who are probably hosed in that scenario, as they have huge commitments but are struggling to raise what they need; Anthropic might last long enough to reassess)
Junk rating from a relatively high likelihood that they can’t pay the people they owe money to. If you buy their shares they are much more likely to go to zero than a more stable company in the near term. So you don’t want to buy anything Anthropic with money that you may need for anything.
High valuation because the public believe that if they do figure it out they could be worth hundreds of trillions. So a lot of people may want to buy it as a speculative bet of ungodly returns
Previous bubble villain Michael Milken and the 80s leveraged buyout bubble made it a name of common parlance because that bubble was built on "junk" bonds.
The old traders of that time who were against what Milken was doing called them "junk" and the name has stuck ever since.
It just means "risky". If you trade bonds it has no association with "bad". It is an inside bond market term, I think that is why it sticks too. It is a fun term if you trade bonds but terrible for communicating to the average person.
If you think it's terrible for communicating to the average person (and I am very much the average person) you could explain it yourself in detail. So I will try, and I will accept constructive criticism:
You are right to imply that it is a sort of consensus rating threshold maintained by the ratings agencies that means their (Anthropic's) debts are not considered investment-grade — that they are speculative, high risk, that they are considered more likely not to be able to repay. It is ultimately the ratings' companies (and therefore some human) decisions as to whether they are above or below this threshold.
But for Anthropic it has concrete impacts, doesn't it? It means they could pay much more for their debt, they may not be able to negotiate long repayment terms, they may need to pay higher underwriters fees, they may be limited by the terms of each individual loan (how much future debt they are allowed to take on, whether they need that lender's approval to restructure their business in even small ways), and most importantly, some institutional investors (pension funds, mutuals, insurance companies, ETFs etc.) will be barred from holding their debt (which drives why their debt will cost more).
All of this means it isn't just everyone thinks they are riskier. It means they will be operating in a more constrained borrowing framework with more interfering lenders.
Frankly I think it is baffling that Anthropic are still headed to an IPO when this is what it could look like on the other side.
Very loosely a 'high' (price over earnings) share price is about growth and exciting prospects; high or well rated bond is about stability. (Not to suggest they move linearly in opposite directions though!)
Historically, the BB category has a 1-year default rate below 1% and a 5-year cumulative rate around 8%.
It is a harsh name for high-yield/speculative bonds, in contrast with e.g. sovereign debt, which is often “investment grade” (depends on the country of course).
Imagine you're about to get on a rocket ship, betting that this famous maverick rocket pilot can take you to Mars in 2 days. He already made it to the moon in 12 hours, record time. And he invented the ship, too. Then the pilot gets caught having an affair with the stewardess, gets fired before the trip, and they bring in a normal airline pilot who's never been on this ship before, never even flown a rocket ship, and who starts talking about good old fashioned normal speeds, and making it to Mars in a few years' time or so. Or, you know what, maybe just orbiting the Earth a few times instead.
You might be tempted to pass on the trip, no? And you wouldn't be the only one. Suddenly this rocket trip which had lots of passengers is completely empty, with no one to fund the trip. This so-called stabilizing force has killed the trip.
There used to be a time when people would invest over the course of decades and enjoy the dividends they received. But these days it’s all just about the short term rewards.
A company can get into the sights of "infinity believers" even if they try not to. Infinityists will honestly believe that the stock is a very good buy and whenever a "stability lover" has to sell, they will outbid the next stabilityist. Price goes up, it becomes more visible to infinityists and so on. Eventually infinityist will outnumber stabilityist and management will enter "or die trying" mode on promises they never made. Or be replaced.
OpenAI not being able to IPO I think is the huge indicator that we are in denial of.
The tide is starting to go out and we are starting to see who is swimming naked.
Jensen and the Jensenverse as the villain of the bubble is the prestige of this bubble's magic trick. That is a show stopper.
OpenaAI as Myspace I think is the second act, yet to come.
Sorry what is this in reference to?
Anyway, ethics has no place in business. If it did, profit would be zero.
It's funny how the problem of Chinese models ended up affecting Nvidia and the US AI industry in general. Just not in the way it was predicted.
That’s just a bear market. Bubbles pop, otherwise we wouldn’t call them bubbles. If you call every downturn a bubble it ceases to be meaningful, and we’d have to come up with a better term for actual bubbles.
All of the investable assets will collapse at the same time. Inflation will evaporate cash. Bonds will worth nothing (if the us gov bothers to repay them).
I think part of a bubble is knowing the problems but participating anyway. Over time then the problems start to feel normal and while things are good you rationalize why maybe the problems aren't such a big deal after all.
Past historical examples of bubbles weren't created around a technology that was overhyped at the start, drew gullible investments in, and was later revealed to be a con/useless/exaggerated/etc and thus the bubble pops dramatically.
The bubbles, like railroads or the internet, grew to their overinflated size because the technology was transformational. I'm not sure why so many pro-AI seem to have this fundamental misunderstanding. Because pointing out that AI lets you code a project that used to take 6 months in 20 minutes doesn't actually rebut the possibility it's a bubble.
This would be like writing letters to the editor in 1845 to the Times of London, to argue that speculation around Railroad Mania turning into a new Tulip Mania is patently absurd. Because riding by rail on a 4 hour route that used to take 3 days by horse and buggy should make anyone with a brain realize that Britain would be covered by railroads in the next few decades as the steam locomotive ushers in a new age.
It's that kind of defensible exuberance that leads everyone and their mother to blindly dump money in to get a piece of the "next big thing". The problem arises because those investments don't actually correlate with its profitability at that particular moment in time, and at some point a correction occurs to re-price based on current/short-term earnings and thus the bubble pops.
Railroads didn't stop being built in 1846 but huge amounts of money was lost as contracts and planned routes were cancelled left and right in the short term.
Since these firms (neoclouds and AI startups) will get consolidated if Nvidia puts too much money into them, I assume the majority of their funds are coming from elsewhere.
So about a third, a sixth, and a twelth of their annual revenue respectively.
I think the larger concern is that both the revenue and assets/agreements depend on Nvidia maintaining sales, market share, and their share of capacity at TSMC/etc... If they run into trouble on any of those fronts, their revenue and assets could take hits from multiple directions.
> Corporate development-led AI equity investments alone exceeded $40 billion in just the first four months of 2026
The accusation in the headline is that this activity contributed to the general shortage of GPUs which would, if true, increase their pricing power and profit margins even on chips sold to other customers. So I don't think it's a direct comparison to their equity deals.
Is this the only reason Nvidia made money? No, obviously. But is it adding fuel to the fire? If there is a bubble will this make the fallout worse? Seems likely.
More importantly this suggests a second plausible reason the board might have wanted to wrest control of the company away from him. (The other hypothetical one being that he was doing illegal stuff.)
All told there have over $500 Billion in equity deals and "future commitments" like above since July and even more after that.
Even for a $4 Trillion company, that's still quite a lot.
IMO Jensen's affairs might have been leaked because of him being out of control and making too many deals like this. The board might have wanted to fire him, but not say the real reason.
How about companies who heavily discount their product to startups to support new uses for their products because it could create new demand?
I’d say “is Nvidia the only investor in this company?” If not then clearly other investors feel like the startup is an investment.
It’s a hell of an allegation to say it’s a pump and dump scheme since those same behaviors can just be smart business practice.
Clearly it's not. That statement makes no sense at all.
At best, financing like that means any honest competitor that doesn't get on the honey train is at massive market disadvantage.
Kinda similar to when niche gets flooded by VC money. Now anyone with better product will get out-competed by people that can sell at cost or below it because they can ride the VC honey train till the competitors are extinct and they have captured the market
It's basically the entire Anthropic IPO model too right? Start with the model, then get into productivity, design, and slowly other businesses and companies with your AI. I agree with another post here that Nvidia didn't seem particularly AGI pilled, but they are certainly DC pilled.
My theory is that once new CEO is found, especially if he comes from the outside, he will be highly incentivized to denounce past sins and disclose as much as possible to start with a clean sheet. I would bet that this is one of the main reasons the stock is tanking. House of cards is about to collapse, and that may be the trigger.
Very much this. If you read the article it mentions that the current acting CEO was against investing into startups and disagreed with Jensen Huang.
Between the circular financing and behaviour some analysts call “channel-stuffing”, it does seem that with Jensen Huang gone, the music is perhaps about to stop.
Channel-stuffing, if it is happening, is usually plain illegal.
The implications are obvious: if people are using GPU scarcity and prices as a proxy for AI demand (and they absolutely have and still are, at every level), and use it as an indication that they must secure GPUs while they can, then it matters a lot if in fact that demand is being padded out and front-loaded in various ways.
How much % of car loans are vendor financed?
For example, here in the UK, that is extremely regulated, and you’re usually not buying with the dealer’s money, or the dealer chain’s money. Sometimes you are buying with the manufacturer’s money (through a regulated subsidiary finance company or joint venture) but most of the time you’re simply buying with money from a regulated finance company, from which the dealer is getting an introducer’s fee (and for which they must agree to be regulated).
(I am not a driver and have no car loans but I am reasonably familiar with the business model from previous client business)
It is my understanding that Nvidia is pretty directly using their own money for this: there is a criticism that they are essentially “selling their balance sheet as a service”, and that their total exposure is about $200 billion.
Nvidia’s loans are not, in that sense, particularly comparable to even the loosest definition of auto loans. Not least because there’s no competition for the products.
This is all putting aside how much money Jensen Huang has persuaded others to loan. Perhaps that side of things won’t go away; I think we might see him carrying on that function in some future capacity. But it will almost inevitably be at a much smaller scale, because the market is significantly less enthusiastic about lending more money.
The concern has to be that ordinary financial institutions might not make such loans to startups, and that therefore Nvidia is using vendor finance to create sales that otherwise would not happen.
Rather than the auto loan system, where essentially the front face of an entire finance industry has moved into the dealerships but you can still get a car loan outside it.
You don’t need to when you have a few dozen customers you’re doing this for. You meet with them and plot world dominance over cocktails.
Auto companies have the structure they do to support 1000s of dealerships and millions of customers.
Vendor finance of the kind Nvidia is doing is different: they are the single vendor for one thing, they are loaning to startups who otherwise might not get funding from banks, it’s coming from the same balance sheet as the product, and these loans are materially causing GPU scarcity.
In general, vendor finance of the kind Nvidia is doing is indicative of an uncertain market, and when it’s the only vendor and it causes the price of the thing to rise, that’s obviously bad.
The industry is very aware that it relies on this for its continuing growth and stability.
A financing company usually is fully taking the credit risk. They have to charge a high interest and hope their underwriting process is sound. That is generally the only way they make money from the transaction.
A vendor can give 0% interest or even a discount to financing customers because they are protected by the profit margin of the transaction. They can also have a looser underwriting process and take more credit risks while doing so.
And yes Jensen lied to shareholders that GPUs aren't that tied to Bitcoin while they were selling trucks of GPUs to interested individuals...