Is this the core of our disagreement?
Is this the core of our disagreement?
Compressed sensing does not violate the Nyquist–Shannon sampling theorem; it can reconstruct certain sparse signals from fewer measurements by using prior knowledge about their structure. This works only under suitable conditions and does not apply to arbitrary signals, such as noise.
https://www.mathworks.com/company/technical-articles/magic-r...
Most of your comments have been like this, it's bizarre.
Almost all real world signals have more discernable structure than noise, almost by definition. So, for any signal you might actually want to sample and reconstruct, you probably have some prior knowledge of the structure, and thus if you can find a sparse basis, can reconstruct with higher fidelity sampling below the frequency the Nyquist-Shannon sampling theorem would suggest.
Fixed that for you.
Not the opposite, don't lie.
Most of your comments have been like this, it's bizarre.
No they haven't.
below the frequency the Nyquist-Shannon sampling theorem would suggest.
Now you're starting to back peddle to something closer to the truth, but you're still conflating the nyquist limit with educated guesses. It's about actually sampling a signal and getting real data, it doesn't say anything about making guesses, using other data etc. These are two different things, not one thing "beating" the other.
An image can be sharpened by taking edge regions and making them even sharper. This has nothing to do with the nyquist limit because it isn't sampling, even though it is creating higher frequencies. Sampling like a camera that skews its pixel reads over time is sampling in a different way, it isn't beating the nyquist limit either.
It seems like this is why you're primarily upset. Fixed that for you. Best of luck dude.
My theory is you either a) don't understand the words "signal reconstruction" or b) don't accept reconstruction to be as philosophically pure as "sampling".
So, to fix your final blocker, tell me, how many times do you think you'd have to listen to a 1 minute track of white noise before you could reliably identify any part of it, or generate it on any instrument, using your human faculties and skills?
Now answer the same question for one piece of your favourite music.
Is the white noise use case even remotely interesting to humans? Basically no, except in random number generation. But, is the music case analogous to anything interesting? Basically, yes, it's analogous to everything we do. From weather forecasting to LHC to James Webb to digital compression to fusion reactor control to...
...and in conclusion, signal reconstruction is extremely useful and interesting, and we no longer ever need to sample at 2x the frequency, ever again, in many, many cases, for imperceptibly perfect reconstruction at that frequency!
I'm having the best luck dude, I get to chat to a cyberdildo! Who has more fun, me or the dildo?
It has nothing to do with philosophy, they are two different things. Everything else you're saying is pointless nonsense. It doesn't matter that you want reality to be different, it just is.
You can try for weird insults or to be patronizing but it just doesn't change these two black and white concepts.