The Claude Delusion
netmeister.org
netmeister.org
Around when AI was getting much better at SQL I was writing SQL everyday at work and had been for years. I don’t think it would’ve been hubris for me to judge that it was getting really good and would shortly be super human at SQL. It would’ve been correct anyway.
he was great but not carmack, bellard, cutler great.
he was an exceptional bully
Coding chops has nothing whatsoever to do with being a decent person. This is, incidentally, why hero worship is so problematic. Somebody proving themselves in one domain should never be taken as an excuse to make them into a role model.
I’m not taking a side on Bill’s skilz. But you can’t compare the two populations so blithely.
There’s something like +6x growth in the industry from the 80’s to 2014 in the US Census alone.
And by my little Google AI search, it might be 1:70 worldwide. I’m no statistician, but maybe pick 10 programmers from 1980 and 700 worldwide today.
https://www.census.gov/content/dam/Census/library/publicatio...
I occasionally have to remind myself of that when I see 13-year-olds today do what I only did at 25. When I was 13, I was learning programming by typing in listings from flea market books, whereas today I’d use highly polished interactive tutorials. Of course people now progress much faster than at a time when it took 3 months of arcane research to make an Ethernet card work on Linux.
Availability is a thing sure, which increase opportunities, but that’s not saying the talent spectrum is different.
In any case the parent's point absolutely stands - I came up in the 90s too and learning to program or make computers do things back then was largely a matter of reading books and talking to people. You had to really want it, because you had to track down and sift through the information.
What's your definition of exceptional? Because that fits mine.
It took some amount of talent to squeeze something useful into computers with those constraints, but the upper limit on complexity also put an upper limit on how exceptional anything could be.
Bill Gates is/was an exceptional businessman. His technical abilities were nothing special.
The reasonable take is that Gates was an exceptional dev for his era for the things he did with the things he had.
But I'm not going to insist any further because after arguing that it was pretty normal for kids to go around and program controlling software for a hydroelectric dam system, I don't think there's much to reason with you.
Thompson uses self-modifying code, so my emulator had to handle that.
Thompson's code is incredibly clever, and back when he wrote it self-modifying code was pretty common. But by modern standards it would have been a maintenance nightmare.
If we assume that you're 95th percentile at writing SQL, it's going to be amazing when companies can just copy-paste the 0.95 SQL dev instead of having to pay for that expertise -- but it doesn't really mean that AI improvement is going exponential, or that we've reach the singularity, or that AI will cure all disease and end human suffering or any of the other nonsense you see AI boosters predicting on this website every day.
It feels like the author is making a bit of a big deal about bill gates declaring superhuman in January when it might take a year or so before it’s undeniable?
Perhaps, but that point was in the 1970s, 50 years before he was evaluating OpenAI, and there were vastly fewer programmers in the 1970s, so "exceptional" then isn't necessarily exceptional now.
A footnote in the article mentions a crucial way he was exceptional: "Bill Gates went to one of the only high schools in the world that had a computer".
Are you going to say that someone like Salieri and Chopin were not technically exceptional because not that many people in the planet had a piano available?
There's a crucial difference: music has not become significantly more complex over the past 200 years. As far as I'm aware, pianos themselves haven't changed significantly since then. In contrast, computers and programming have changed dramatically since the 1970s. Whatever Gates did in the 1970s, it's not clear how 2020s Bill Gates, who stopped programming full-time decades ago, is qualified to evaluate contemporary programming.
1. Can someone _who haven't programmed for 50 years_ correctly evaluate current coding AI, and 2. Is what made a good programmer in the 70s the same as what make is good today to evaluate current coding AI.
If someone did competitive bike racing in 1970 and stopped since then, he probably forgot a lot of things and is not a good judge on current cycling. But if he were to be magically transported from that time, I don't see what he would lack. Sure, bikes are different (and better), nutrition is better understood, and so on. But the core job is the same.
I actually don't. See my other comment: "You're conflating two different things, (1) difficulty in principle with (2) practical knowledge and experience." https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50498280
> competitive bike racing
You cherry-picked an activity that depends primarily on the physical limits of the human body, which as far as I'm aware hasn't evolved significantly since the 1970s.
Still, training and sports science has evolved, as you note: "nutrition is better understood". (There's also the matter of doping and cheating.) Thus, I suspect that an exceptional racer magically transported from the 1970s might not be as exceptional now. Moreover, the Earth's population is larger now, and bike racing has become popularized by TV coverage, attracting more enthusiasts, not to mention more money, so the competition is now tougher. You can see this even more clearly in sports that were traditionally very white for socioeconomic reasons, such as golf and tennis: more non-white people are now competing in those sports, opening to a global population. At the top, the bar has been raised.
Yes. C++ was created in 1985. JavaScript was created in 1995. I could go on and on. If a 70s programmer frozen in ice was unthawed today, that person would be unable to get a programming job.
The funny thing is that contemporary professional programmers who rely on Claude are already complaining that they've forgotten how to program, so how much could Bill Gates possibly remember 50 years later?
You're conflating two different things, (1) difficulty in principle with (2) practical knowledge and experience.
Could Bill Gates learn contemporary programming if he put in the time and effort? Perhaps. The point is that he hasn't. Although he was a 1970s programming expert, he's a 2020s programming n00b.
The job postings that require things like "5 years of experience with C++" or "5 years of experience with JavaScript" are really dumb, because anyone who really understands programming can do that in any programming language, after a few days needed to memorize its quirks, to avoid checking its specification continuously.
The number of innovations in programming languages that have been done after 1980 is extremely small in comparison with those done before 1980.
> after a few days
I disagree but consider the response too dismissive to even argue with seriously.
Actually, here's a serious argument: if you think of programming merely as knowing programming language syntax, you're missing the most important parts. Maybe we should phrase it more accurately as software engineering than computer programming. The problems that you face are vastly more difficult than satisfying a compiler or interpreter.
I would point to Microsoft's own recent global service outage. I guess they should have just called up old exceptional Bill to save them, eh?
It's a shocking misinterpretation after I wrote, "If a 70s programmer frozen in ice was unthawed today, that person would be unable to get a programming job."
To quote another of your comments, you don't _think_ there is timeless programming skill. I do. Sure, there are areas of expertise (embedded, parallel, graphics, etc.), but the basic abilities (pre AI) stay the same.
I don't see why a good biologist, pianist, mathematician or scientist taken out of the 70s couldn't be good today. You seem to believe in some exceptionalism for computer science and software development. I don't see good foundations for this argument.
I would note that you've moved the goalposts from "exceptional" to merely "good".
> You seem to believe in some exceptionalism for computer science and software development. I don't see good foundations for this argument.
It's simple: computing changes and advances much more rapidly than any of those other subjects. I addressed this point in another comment: "music has not become significantly more complex over the past 200 years. As far as I'm aware, pianos themselves haven't changed significantly since then." https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50498199
When Bill Gates cofounded Microsoft in 1975, personal computers did not yet exist; the Apple II arrived in 1977. LLMs did not exist, smartphones did not exist, the world wide web did not yet exist, and the precursor of the internet was just getting started. The computing world was entirely different. Bill's previous programming expertise is now obsolete.
How did exceptional (or good) programmers managed to stay relevant through those 50 years (which is just slightly longer than a typical career length)?
Note that LLMs are, in my opinion, a different thing. Similar to what cars did to horseshoes makers. You cannot pivot around this, however good you are.
Of course not. Everyone programming today was born ignorant of the internet, and of everything else.
"Could Bill Gates learn contemporary programming if he put in the time and effort? Perhaps. The point is that he hasn't. Although he was a 1970s programming expert, he's a 2020s programming n00b." https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50498280
> How did exceptional (or good) programmers managed to stay relevant through those 50 years (which is just slightly longer than a typical career length)?
By putting in the work to keep their skills current.
They were not "magically transported", as you put it in another comment, from the beginning of their career to the end of their career. They had to go step by step, methodically.
They believe you are attacking the old programmers, but you are just stating the common advice: keep learning.
The extra programmers of today have filled the voids in the distribution of programmers vs. skill, but in the best case for the present programmers they have not shifted the distribution towards a higher skill. If there was any shift in the distribution, it seems more likely that it was towards a lower skill.
I am pretty certain that any programmer who was exceptional in the 1970s would still be exceptional today.
Several decades ago, when I was very young, I reverse engineered a few Microsoft programs for CP/M, including the BASIC interpreter, the FORTRAN compiler and the FORTRAN run-time library.
At least the BASIC interpreter is likely to have included code written by Bill Gates. Given the hardware constraints, those programs were well written. They also included a lot of assembly language tricks that would not be used today, but which were justified in a program that had to run on very weak CPUs and using very little memory.
At that time, I considered those programs very instructive.
2) With regard to timeless inborn ability, I think it's obvious that you will end up with higher achievers if you start with a much larger population all working on the same activity.
I don’t think the author realizes that “AP” is an exam for American high schoolers. Gates is only claiming he made new test questions at a high school+ level that wouldn’t have been in the training set for AI. I don’t see how it’s so unbelievable he could do that.
It’s unbelievable because Gates is neither a biology exam author nor a biology textbook author, so how would he even know what’s in the training set for AI? To know, you would need to be an experienced biology teacher and survey the pedagogical literature.
When I was studying for AP Calculus or Literature etc I’m sure I could’ve made decent sample questions.
Coming up with such questions is not easy, and just because you did well on a test or "kept up with the field a bit" does not mean you can ASK such questions very well.
And would fit the fact that he funded biotech R&D too.
More like half of HNs believe they're near-experts in some random field.
To flip it around, I have friends who I would consider (hobbyist) experts in CS. The geneticist is much better at C++ and OOP than me, the geologist knows a lot about 3d modelling and the whole GIS world, and the economist knows way more about DS, AI and statistics. Who am I to say they aren't experts? This kind of rigid division of field and expertise made no sense in university, and it only breaks apart more as we get older and more experienced.
Heh, well, by coincidence, before I became a programmer I spent (too many) years as a PhD candidate in philosophy, and I'm skeptical about the extent to which undergraduates can be considered experts. ;-)
That was a long time ago, though, and despite my experience, I've undoubtedly fallen far behind the current work in the field.
I should hope so, after paying so much tuition!
> knowing more than high-school curriculum - which is the bar we're discussing
No, that's not the bar you were discussing. Originally you said "near-experts", but now you've lowered the bar way down.
If you had said "half of HNers probably know more than a high schooler in some random field they haven't had formal training in", then I wouldn't have argued, but that also wouldn't have been any kind of defense of Bill Gates.
Given his track record and the state of AI today, I know which one I find more likely.
The message was more abstract, why focus on one (poor) example?
Take the claim of superhuman for example. If an AI is as good as Bill Gates at coding, but is relentless and tireless, then that is fairly called superhuman, the same way a drilling machine was superhuman relative to John Henry.
It was absolutely not a given that next-token prediction would scale to the point that it could answer outside of its training domain (this is the point about “made up questions”, it was important to test it on material outside of the training set since the scale of training was yet-unheard-of at the time).
Further, the success of post-training on verifiable tasks (coding) was also a complete shock that changed the world overnight. LLMs jumped the “I can make code” to “I confidently can make code that solves your problem” chasm suddenly, and it has changed the industry.
For someone so invested in this from the early days (remember the scale of Microsoft’s commitment) it is entirely logical that testing things “on day one” would occur and this would be a much bigger shock compared to most people that learned of advances at the same time as the rest of the world. (There are huge delays between research capabilities and shipping)
Then immediately goes on to say that his comments about AI coding are arrogant despite being an expert in that field with more experience than nearly anyone.
Unsure how to interpret that.
Gates in the modern era would probably do great writing a small application designed to be extremely small and run on very limited resources. If your experience is targeting applications to run on systems with 2MB to 4MB of RAM at most and MS-DOS lower memory limitations, that's its whole own historical skill set and knowledge...
Being CEO does not involve a lot of coding. Yes he was an expert 40 years ago, but a lot has happened in 40 years
Nothing annoys me more than business folks who try to claim street cred from their halcyon days as a programmer.
These folks are consistently the ones who make the worst decisions because they falsely believe their intuition of how software worked 20 years ago is valuable insight for technical decisions being made today.
Then ask Claude!
I always get the "ick" when I see someone successful in one domain assume they're automatically brilliant in all others. Like someone who made a fortune selling B2B SaaS going on a podcast talking nonsense about "quantum" or whatever.
The lightbulb moment for me was when I gave Claude Code a tough reverse-engineering problem: understanding how a complex, proprietary encoding scheme worked, then building an encoder and decoder. There are some additional complicating factors that I can't disclose, because this was for work, but it was a tough problem.
For context, I've been doing RE for over 25 years. I'm not the best in the world, but I'm pretty good at it when I can find the time.
A coworker and I had spent about a week on the work, and I estimated it would take us another 2-3 to complete the work. We had figured out how about 3/4 of the messages were encoded, but the rest just didn't make sense.
I gave Claude Code our notes, and in 15 minutes it had finished figuring out the rest of the protocol and built a command-line decoder. I asked it to add an encoding feature, and in another ten minutes, it had done that as well. It tested all of its own code extensively using our corpus of real data.
The decoder worked perfectly on all of our existing captures as well as new data collected after that.
I had to make a small change to the encoder that was related to one of the things I can't disclose. I don't hold that against the model, because it didn't have access to the real product to test its output against. Making the change took maybe an hour because there was some trial-and-error involved.
That kind of capability is a genuine game-changer, especially when the interface is "describe the result you want in natural language". Ten years ago, I would have thought a truly useful natural language interface to a complex system was 20 to 30 years away at best.
Being able to quickly clone nearly all of the functionality of Adobe's entire product suite is another favourite example of mine.
This is by far the most disruptive technology I've seen introduced in my lifetime. A lot of people are using it for questionable purposes, but that always happens when people are figuring out how to make the best use of something new.
The original v-tailed Beechcraft Bonanza used to be known as the "v-tailed doctor killer".
I'm smart enough to know that I can't make a distinction between my expertise or luck for the success of those project. But my ego wants it to be my expertise because I'm the only constant in those projects
In any system of competing agents (such as human beings) where the reward for performance can enhance performance, will always result in even minor random differentials in initial performance exponentially accumulating until one or a handful of individuals dominate. In such a system, only a small portion of success can be attributed to innate skills. So it's true that success in itself, while signaling fitness to survive, does not necessarily signal an outsized ability to make accurate judgements.
I'm not entirely clear what the second part of the article is trying to convey. Is it that highly successful individuals attribute their success entirely to their skill and therefore when a machine is able to replicate their skillset, they are surprised and consider the technology to be world-altering?
Not doubting the intelligence of these individuals, just saying they sure tend to undervalue domain specific expertise. I don't know who Elon consulted about his cybertruck, but it wasn't truck people.
I do worry that AI exasperates this problem as a quick few queries and thoughtful questions have certainly given me over-confidence in a new subject. You don't know what you don't know.
https://ourworldindata.org/profile/co2/united-states
The second chart is the one I’m looking at. Where is the 15 year reversal? If zoom in I see a small uptick. Not a 15 year trend reversal.
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2026-10-28/us-data-c...
I keep hearing this AI water and energy panic stuff. I’m a believer in facts, so I go looking for it, and it’s just not there. Water use is similar to golf courses and light agriculture, though I can see it being a problem in places like the Southwest. The electricity use is decent but not at the levels people are losing their minds over.
It’s just not there.
I can see some of the complaints over noise and political corruption like special tax breaks and deals.
Unless something catastrophic happens, [0] construction four years out is effectively locked in. When what's being constructed is expected to increase CO2 emissions by ~50% after it's built, it's quite reasonable to assert that the LLM Industry has reversed our collective work on cutting CO2 emissions. It's exceedingly reasonable to bitch bitterly about it when those very same entities driving the construction today were screaming left and right about all of the initiatives they'd been championing to reduce power consumption and Save The Planet and whatnot just a few years ago.
[0] ..such as a fuckoff-huge bubble that's being used to justify said construction messily exploding...
Chip efficiency gains will mean that by 2030 you’ll be getting 100X the inference throughput on half the power. All this construction is not necessary.
They're in line with what's needed to meet the revenue projections of the LLM companies. Your "100x the inference" assertion ignores the most expensive part of the work of creating SOTA LLMs... the "training". That is what the DCs are primarily being built to do.
In fact, using AI requires also inference power that needs to be closer to the consumers to reduce latency.
Probably because of economics, politics, and logistics. Much easier and safer to have a bunch of relatively small projects running in a large variety of jurisdictions than one fuckoff-huge project that's the size of all of the smaller projects combined, don't you think? There's probably some folksy saying about that sort of thing...
> Why not just put the data centers near clean power sources?
a) Unless you live in Texas, folks in the US are connected to a nationwide electricity-distribution grid. Folks in nearly all other other countries are in similar situations. Proximity to generation is nice, but not mandatory.
b) If there was grid capacity available to run the new datacenters that are in various stages of project completion, why would they be running on-site natural-gas fired turbines? Those are way less efficient and way more expensive to run than grid-scale generation facilities. That'd be a huge waste of money if the datacenter operators could hook into the grid, yeah?
> ...that needs to be closer to the consumers to reduce latency.
Needs? No. RTT all the way across the globe is right around 250 milliseconds; I checked. For this part of these sorts of programs, servers in the same region as their clients are nice to have but not at all required.
I also found that these projections are 15 years ahead and assume nearly all power is from gas when battery and solar costs are still falling geometrically and data center demand has reignited modular nuclear interest.
I’m generally skeptical of all predictions of the form “look at this terrifying thing that happens if we extrapolate the current trends indefinitely!” See: “The Population Bomb” by Paul Erlich and countless other doom predictions of a similar nature.
Not being Pollyanna either. Just being realistic.
1. Trump's War
2. Falling birth rates
3. Petro vs Electro state directions (Russia -> US -> China)
There are also unknowns around the thawing of the permafrost at northern latitudes.
But hey. FAFO. We will live and adapt. Humans are like cockroaches, as a bio professor said to me once, and he explained that this is not an insult.
Hyperscalers want to build out enough that the trend will reverse. How much is t.b.d., America is likely to slow down the buildout
Or is the theme of the piece that one ought to have epistemic humility?
But the thing is, this piece itself also makes claims about psychology, power theory, and human nature to some degree, which is ironic. But that can't be it. Because this piece has no epistemic humility in it.
Then, if we demand according to what this piece says, in the end it comes down to "no one can test AI outside the major they studied in university" — but honestly, isn't it just a matter of buying the textbooks and papers and testing AI with them?
It's a slightly difficult problem.
These kind of people are where they are because they got lucky and exploited a lot of people.
Bill Gates made his fortune gaining and enforcing an illegal monopoly.
But they do get to spend as much time as they like talking with leading experts in any field. I have a hard time seeing that as a disadvantage.
The theme of this piece is, in fact, "don't absolutize your own standards" — that successful people forget the contingency of their success, forget the situation and context of their judgment, and treat it as a universally correct judgment. But the problem lies in the writing itself that carries this piece's theme.
A doctor can smoke while telling a patient that smoking is bad — that's not a problem at all. The biggest contradiction in this piece is that, while warning against "absolutizing one's own standards outside one's own field," it reinforced the psychological parts without any argument or evidence. Honestly, everyone has that degree of contradiction in a homepage essay. So do I.
But separate from that, the difficulty in reading this piece is that if you're going to demand intellectual humility, you should at least be consistent within the text. You can criticize the act of reinforcing one's own standards outside one's field. The problem is that it's hard when, within the text, the author violates the very standards he set. I also tend to think this is to some degree a general human trait. Everyone has some logical leaps... it's not a bad thing, but that's how I am.
Also, Dunning-Kruger effect doesn’t exist. It’s autocorrelation.
Of course not, but that's not what's being argued. If you believed you could authoritatively declare what AI is or is not, that would be different, though.
> couldn't Bill Gates have studied biology hard and understood things outside his own field too?
Yes but he would still be a dilettante. Belief to the contrary is more likely to be an indication of engineer's disease.
The point of the matter is that the intellectual humility the author of this piece advocates isn't present in this piece. What papers are cited for the psychological claims the author of this piece makes? Of course, there's no need to do that in a blog essay. But the target of this piece's criticism is the absolutization of one's own standards and epistemic humility, and the problem is that this piece also commits that contradiction. This is a matter of the piece's level. I respect the intellectual aesthetics of people who like this kind of writing, but it's not my taste.
What I am seeing in the article is an unchecked case of cognitive dissonance. That's just the overwhelming sense I get. You identified it as self-contradiction. The reason I label it cognitive dissonance is that the author is arguing against something that they themselves are projecting; that subject matter experts in one domain are overconfident in another.
This article's self-fulfilling prophecy is that it will one day be used as an argument from authority, if it hasn't already.
I see biases claims against billg can be applied against the post author.
After having read your blog i can assert you've demonstrated that effect on yourself. Bill has all capability and credentials proven so we know this guy is an authority on software engineering topics, you have zero if i'm not mistaken.
Gates doesn't have the biology credentials. He's a pedophile, to top it off, so most probably that's where the article should have started with. It's telling that for most of the last 30 or so years the most wealthy person on this planet has been a pedophile, come to think of it maybe we (the human species) do deserve what's coming.
The article author accuses him of thinking himself an expert for that reason, I think the article author does not know what an AP exam is.
It's absolutely infuriating because it allows people with a lot of money tell you they know what they're talking about without proving it. Your money is your perceived effort, no matter how you acquired it.
Notably hanging out with Epstein
I would say he has more authority on software engineering topics than most people on earth, but that’s just me.
You are just focusing on the tech bit. Bill gates never was a very good person to begin with and then he did some stuff that pretty much offset whatever good he did.
As for software engineering: if you think Bill Gates is an authority in the field I would like to introduce you to Donald Knuth, Peter Norvig, Fabrice Bellard, Dennis Ritchie, Linus Torvalds and many others. Bill Gates wouldn't make the top 100.
> I would bet they don't.
I mean, how many "But but but antitrust!" and "Nobody got fired for buying Microsoft!" excuses can be made for Microsoft being where it is today?
I am focusing on the tech bit because the subthread was about his technical skills. As an engineer and a tech executive, everything I've read about him places him far above most people one could name. I also think he ranks very highly as a general scientific and systems thinker. As an example, he was harping on about pandemics long before COVID happened. He's been harping about AI and jobs these days, which I think many here would also agree with.
If we were discussing him as a person I have a more mixed opinion of him, but it's way more positive than the hate he gets around here, which I find hilariously misplaced.
He missed the coming interconnectedness of the machines and instead presumed that every computer was going to be a fancy copy machine calculator (that will never talk to others, thus security is not needed).
A massive hole in perception.
billg wrote the “Internet Tidal Wave” memo in May of 1995! This was an era when the dominant enterprise IT infrastructure was heavyweight (Windows!) client/server and homes were just starting to connect to the internet via dialup en masse.
Microsoft proceeded to pivot so successfully that they monopolized the web browser market alongside winning a massively profitable position in enterprise “intranet” apps and TCP/IP-based servers.
Microsoft missed mobile, not the Internet.
I’d say Gates’ timing was pretty good!
The history of AOL predates this and Netscape IPO'd a few months after Gates' writing. They filled gaps that MS was obviously missing.
I'm not sure I do, which is why I find it puzzling when I hear/read people saying that LLMs write better code than they can, or at least code that's just as good (re-quoting Bill Gates from the article: "I could see that they are as good as I am").
It's now possible to "vibecode" entire applications without taking a single look at the code, but that’s not what my comment is about.
LLM-generated code isn't meant to be read by humans. LLMs specialize in generating text, and they're very good at it. But what they can't do is generate text as as if it were written by a human, for a human. I get this feeling from LLM-generated code, but also from most of the LLM-generated fiction, instructions, reports, etc.
Designing new algorithms is where the real skill is, but an average programmer will never do this, and even a 10x programmer will do it maybe a few times in their lifetime at most.
there's no law that says you can't be top in two fields at once.
Money gets a lot simpler when it's on cash basis in an ordinary bank.
A 401k is not a magical guarantee that your retirement will go well.
But today’s agents are “superintelligent,” the same way that trains are “superlocomotive”—that is, faster than a running human. And they can carry more. Trains are just better at getting from point A to point B than humans.
That doesn’t mean trains are a superrace and humans are obsolete, just that we’ve built machines that can do something more effectively than our bodies are physically capable of, as usual.
Intelligence isn’t what makes us human. A human who can’t play chess or write a sonnet is still a human being.
They are called “agents” because they can, and do, perform actions autonomously on our behalf. Virtual agents are not a new thing.
We have a serious problem in human society where people delude themselves routinely to believe expertise in one area magically translates to areas one has no experience. This is probably a human survival trait. It makes no sense, from a logical perspective: to venture into an area where one is educated enough to understand the danger of operating outside one's understanding is well ingrained by our educations, but we routinely ignore that like it does not exist. Perhaps this arrogance is how man's stupid will to force forward becomes our survival fitness.
> Now Bill Gates surely has shown an interest in biology and, through his work with the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, has probably read a lot of articles and research in this field. But the hubris to think himself a subject matter expert able to make up advanced, novel questions in a scientific field outside his own and suitable to assess AI's true capabilities and then being "shocked" that it could answer these questions makes my point.
The author seems to have a weird fetish with “expertise” and gatekeeping opinions so that they can only be expressed by Ph.D.s. The above anecdote was about high school biology. Any educated adult should be more than capable of generating “novel” questions in areas they are familiar with. It’s bizarre to shout “dunning-krueger” about topics that are absolutely within the intellectual ambit of Bill Gates.This piece reads very much like the conclusion was arrived at before any of the evidence, and even though the arguments were flimsy that didn’t stop the author from including them. Gee, I guess they’re unqualified to have an opinion on this topic and should just shut their mouth and let someone with a Ph.D. speak.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vp5qsEuUOWo
Same idea, more general and eloquent
That, and, they are pitifully ahistorical people. Today's industry leaders are not sufficiently schooled in constructivism. No, I don't mean they all need to become radical constructivists, but they should all at least gain a passing familiarity with Foucault before they continue fucking with humanity's social mores and environments with impunity.
They won't, of course, because they are decidedly unreflective (see Andreessen), unphilosophical people. They are, oftentimes, the marquee examples of 'soulless' people fueled only by the incentive structures put before them by the economy. Money. Clout. "Progress". It's telling that, beyond the many examples of hubris like that of Gates, basically zero technologists have come out and examined the unspoken assumptions behind such terms as "progress", "alignment", "intelligence" and the difficult social problems fixing these terms would entail. Moreover, they interpret all of these terms using some reified capitalistic gloss and go on their merry way, because, in spite of their constant proclamations to the contrary, most of them are not, in fact, very intelligent beyond being savvy businessmen.
The employees bear the brunt of actual technical intelligence. Leadership bears little more than a passing ability to navigate an economic structure that, let's face it, is already very forgiving to them and essentially places little to no responsibility on them after certain levels of scale are achieved. But none of that scale is possible without the vast legions of employees. Oftentimes the 'genius idea' is about 0.5% of the actual success of an endeavor, yet we cling to an old "great men of history" form of thinking and allow the public to prop up these individuals as though they are demigods.
This is so lazy and petty it made me stop reading. Whatever you think of Musk, it's trivially verifiable that the emerald mine thing is a myth.
And in case you think I'm some evil right-wing troll, here's the LA Times telling you the same thing:
> Over the years, Musk critics have accused him of getting a leg up in life because of money his father made from emerald mines. Isaacson, who interviewed Errol Musk, reports that Errol struck a black-market deal to receive emeralds from three mines in Zambia to cut in Johannesburg, but that Errol did not have an ownership stake in the mines. He reportedly earned $210,000 from those mines before the business collapsed in the 1980s.
> But Isaacson calls it a “myth” that Elon emigrated in 1989 with wealth from his father’s emerald business. Isaacson writes that Errol’s emerald business had become “worthless” years earlier, and that he only gave his son $2,000 in traveler’s checks when Elon Musk moved to Canada that year.
I mean...really. The LA Times hates reporting this so much that they put idiotic scare quotes around the words "myth" and "worthless", but they still have to print it, because it comes directly from one of the eminent biographers in the world today, who interviewed Musk's father.
https://www.latimes.com/entertainment-arts/books/story/2023-...
Or someone has the impression that Ai can code as well as them (and find errors) but at 10x the speed or more. They then conclude that human ability and superhuman speed is superhuman in total.
You can look at this article like a chimp who envies on an alpha while having “Meister” in his domain name. You can look at it as descent to a group of chimps that have gone to pluck a field of toxic mushrooms.
When you look above the primate behaviors, the only question that matters is not if the new stick invented is better than having more chimps, but if the new stick will be used to grow the chimp universe or to shrink the # of chimps in the universe so one tribe gets the universe - under the premise of “all those chimps are ruining my universe”. It’s not whether it’s smarter or more powerful, but how its used. The confident will try more things than the doubtful. The scared will try less - will the stick be used to scare you into not trying?
> "Take note of the emphasis I added: the very notion that something else could be "as good as I am" is, first of all, hard to believe and secondly necessarily means that it's "superhuman".
Unironically, I recommend psychedelics. The right experience will make you aware of just how tiny a part of a vast universe you are -- and obliterate any sense of hubris.It's all so short sighted and anyone supporting this behavior is anti-humanity.
That's just being human. If we step outside the tech echo chamber, many many people feel this way towards "tech bros." Do or don't be surprised when they give us a comeuppance.
Seeing the ultra wealth playboys who brought them addictive technology and are automating away their jobs.
Calling it indoctrination is a fallacy. Talking with non-tech people about these things will uncover as much.
The only fallacy is your implied claim that if non-technical people think it then it can't be indoctrination.
If yes, what about you, compared to them, makes you immune to indoctrination?
My main counterpoint datum is the US midterm election exit polls. People said affordability and corruption are their top issues and that they are interconnected. Tech bros are their exemplar de jour - with good reason.
If half the population consume the same sort of media that's all saying the same thing then they're very likely to believe the same thing. They will believe they noticed something, when in fact they were told it over and over. Pick whichever half you like. Just as I don't trust a nationalist's opinion on immigration, I don't trust a Marxist's opinion on the wealthy.
As for "valid feelings" I agree this is about feelings and not thoughts, but I don't know what a valid or invalid feeling is.
The naivety... to assume people agree with or support everything they read or watch. How are we to know what others think without consuming their content? How are we to persuade them of weak points in their arguments if we do not know the foundations?
What indoctrination have you yourself been subjected to? You seem to be stuck on a bipolar view, defined by the extremes (a minority), in a nuanced world that is growing increasingly tired of the extremes, their reductionist perspectives, and their bickering.
Of course we all have biases. But calling people "tech bros" is the reductionist, bipolar view you're now criticising. That's the thing I was pointing out all along.
How much percentage of money does a billionaire donate vs a middle class fellow? He can donate to african or asian countries. A middle class american is the top 1 percentile of the world in money. Why is he claiming to be better than a billionaire who donates some of his money while he himself donates literally none?
He finds it so astounding to be himself, to feel like the Main Character of the World that he considers this evidence that the world he experiences is a simulation. The more humbling proposition -- that the world is largely random and he just happens to be the guy who kept rolling sixes -- is less compelling.
Edit: I think this is the clip I was remembering https://x.com/firesidealpha/status/2112531407390343670 but he's said similar things in other venues.
This will be the thing that really hurts the frontier labs. I believe they will be sued into oblivion and regulated in surprising ways.
And being more intelligent than average makes you...by definition superior at being intelligent.
Also Bill Gates is highly intelligent, rich, and successful, so... 'more superior' by definition than 99% of us (Yep me too).
And I guess the author also has some sense of superiority, because I'd certainly be too embarrassed to post this anywhere if I wrote this shit.
I like that the article just tries to pass off a computer program coding at the level of humans (not to mention solving Millennium Problems) as something that should be just be totally unsurprising. Bill Gates is just a dumb arrogant tech bro to be surprised that a neural network exceeds his abilities at coding.
This would be like if I went in my garage, spent several weeks with the 3d printer and CNC machine to build a robot that can "dance", then I made a video of me dancing about as well as your average dad at a wedding along with my dancing robot and I said "this thing can dance better than me!", therefore: "Ha, your robot sucks! You must think you're Baryshnikov if you call that dancing". I mean this is kind of sad.
Slightly more than a couple of years ago, just observing an LLM coherently doing work at the academic level of a sixth grader was brand new to all of us. Which was objectively impressive. It doesnt matter "so what? anyone can do 6th grade math"....this..is not..the point...
edit: the point they want to make, that these people are not qualified to make dire predictions about "superintelligence", and that they see themselves fit to determine "superintelligence" based on watching the robots be smarter than them, is one I generally agree with, and their certainty originates from a kind of hubris. but it's not a hubris you can assign to the general LLM-using population as this seems to be doing. Most people using LLMs think the "superintelligence" thing is a load of bunk (probably moreso than the general population who seem to be cowering in terror).
Being "human" is ill-defined. Being "super-human" even more. LLMs abilities are superior to humans in many ways, sure. So does my calculator. So does an excavator.
LLMs are "super-humans" in novel ways, sure. But machines having superior abilities than humans' is nothing new. Nothing.
Can we move on and make something good now?
Sure, the biology point is fair. The rest is very silly. It moving on to say Bill Gates is therefore wrong to fear the pace of AI improvement is extremely silly.
Biases and heuristics have become somewhat mainstream “intellectualism”, but just like people using the words prolific and myriad incorrectly, is leveraged here to a false conclusion.
The anti-AI narrative continues, to the detriment of those who listen to its self-destructive guidance that equates excessive enthusiasm with delusion.
> The anti-AI narrative continues, to the detriment of those who listen to its self-destructive guidance
Can you expand on your view of the narrative (which one) and why it is self-destructive (which one)?
The technology is useful (while imperfect)
* The Claude Delusion (2026-11-13)
* This is not sustainable (2026-10-27)
* 'Winning AI' (2026-10-01)
* Everybody's Lost Their Minds (2026-09-16)
Definitely a trap I need to keep in mind as I blog since I don’t want to become like that.
But I was there. He worked really, really fucking hard. As did most of the early crowd. If you're asking yourself how people back then worked so hard, just realize that there are drugs that can help you do that.
The true integrity and value of this blog post depends on your own interpretation of the author's interpretation of the hour-long podcast plus his supporting snipes toward Gates, Musk, Trump and other Tech Bros (read: Bad Nerds).
As an appendix I want to link to this submission from 3 months ago:
It's where broader society is at, like it or not. They are angry at the "coastal elites" which now includes the tech sector.
Ugh. You're right. And I'm not surprised to see these sort of complaints coming from the opposite side.
It's coming from both sides now. The political bipolarization fever may have broken in the US. The growing division is between haves and have nots.
Perhaps they are right and we are not https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vp5qsEuUOWo
However, today's models have extremely jagged intelligence even within fields they're extremely capable in.
Like most people here, I use Claude and other models daily and I used them primarily in the context of building a very complex software project. Claude is brilliant at writing code at, in very clean and well defined codebases, where its being asked to build something that fits well within the preexisting patterns.
Someone non-technical who does a lot of vibe coding recently asked why I couldn't just tell Claude to go build some feature into the project and call it a day? And it's genuinely hard to explain to people who are not both experts broadly in the field and experts in the specifics of the problem why this such a bad idea. And annoyingly it's not that Claude won't produce something that works, it will produce something that makes several extremely bad assumptions and defensively codes in those assumptions. And even when you explain this, the question then changes to, "yeah, but you could just ask Claude to fix that".
My default way of working today is to start 90% of my projects by simply asking in a few paragraphs what I want, seeing what Claude builds then spending half a day working through it, explaining all the wrong assumptions it's made, then reaching a clean and maintainable solution at the end.
However, I have been on the other side of this and I've felt magic of Claude when I've got it to write code I don't really understand. On the surface it seems to be able to do everything I ask stupidly fast. It's better than any human you could ever work with. But who knows what it's doing under the hood... My guess is that you simply can't keep building like that for long because while it will do everything you ask, the foundations of what it's building on are basically non-existent – and anyone whose worked on a serious software project before knows the foundations of any software are by far the most important things in the long-term robustness and maintainability of the project.
I guess what I'm saying is that many people who are non-experts in the field or non-exports in the specific problem within the fields they're asking AI to do things are largely delusional about what AI can and can't do. It absolutely can create a simple CRUD app, but it will not build a complicated distributed system and process millions of requests a day with five 9s of uptime.
That's not to say it will never happen. I think it will, but there's some things that need to be figured out first.
I was working with someone earlier this week who was telling me about how he convinced GPT-6.1 his name was an an XSS attack string. I don't think you could convince 1 in a million humans that your legal name is genuinely <script>alert("hello!");</script> and yet these models are supposed to be experts in domains like cyber security and super intelligent? It's honestly staggering how stupid they can be whilst also being so competent at a surface level.