> Which is the more successful ?
Who thinks like this? Who sees what I just saw and has this thought? A wasted opportunity for some wonder and joy.
> Which is the more successful ?
Who thinks like this? Who sees what I just saw and has this thought? A wasted opportunity for some wonder and joy.
The Falcon program is very much a part of the learning experience to had a direct contribution to technology and because of the limitations, the team at SpaceX designed Starship.
So how many Falcon flights are we going to count for Starship ? Sure it could be said that the design has basically stopped being a contributor of technology to Starship but theres still at least a few dozens during the learning phase.
If we aggregate some of Falcon and the current Starship program thats pretty close 100, and we are clearly not ready for even manned flight let alone the full program.
https://www.reddit.com/r/RKLB/comments/1bep3si/spacex_raptor...
All 20 missions I named are official Apollo program launches, which contributed directly to Saturn V development, yes.
And as for Mercury, Gemini, and Falcoln, all absolutely contributed to their successor's development. That was their purpose.
> Im not denying the forefathers of the Saturn V
Seems like you were.
I think your questions are pointless and intended to incite controversy. They betray ignorance of the practicalities of large scale engineering projects, strip each effort of their context unnecessarily, and cast a competition where there is only combined effort extending scientific and human achievement.
> I think your questions are pointless and intended to incite controversy. They betray ignorance of the practicalities of large scale engineering projects, strip each effort of their context unnecessarily, and cast a competition where there is only combined effort extending scientific and human achievement.
No you are the one who misunderstanding large projects. The current timeline shows SpaceX is very far away from even getting to the moon let alone Mars.
You have made no attempt to address the very real problem of understanding how far away from success Starship is, because you know very well the actual number is impossible to know. You fail to appreciate this and pretend this unknown is not a major problem.
When knowledge was shared with you, you argued with it and moved the goalposts rather than learning from it.
> No you are the one who misunderstanding large projects.
I hope thinking that makes your day easier.
> You have made no attempt to address the very real problem of understanding how far away from success Starship is
Because I don't think it makes sense to guess at completion dates. Research and development is done when it's done.
> because you know very well the actual number is impossible to know. You fail to appreciate this and pretend this unknown is not a major problem.
Of course the number is impossible to know. I've never suggested otherwise. Milestones, however, indicate progress.
Uncertainty is a real challenge for planning, but it's not evidence of failure. Every completed milestone provides more information about the remaining challenges.
I appreciate the progress made by both Apollo and Starship. I don't need one to fail for the other to be an extraordinary achievement.
Your reply was due to your confusion about my statement. Nobody gained any knowledge from that - we all know about Apollo and previous programs - its public knowledge.
> Because I don't think it makes sense to guess at completion dates. Research and development is done when it's done.
Exactly - this is no different from my statement that about 100 launches.
The full history of luanches of SpaceX together does amount to a large number, it doesnt matter how or which you count its a very large number just like 100.
>> because you know very well the actual number is impossible to know. You fail to appreciate this and pretend this unknown is not a major problem.
> Of course the number is impossible to know. I've never suggested otherwise. Milestones, however, indicate progress.
Exactly and SS is still at a very early stage.
SS with its multiple coordinate systems and tanks of fuel in space is a far more complex system, all that complexity and new technologies mean it will always require more launches to develop and more to complete a single mission.
I am simply pointing out that missions are expensive. The US gov is the only entity willing and capable to meet that cost. SpaceX does not have the use case or economic opayback to support over a 100 missions to get to the Moon or Mars.
Im sur eyou will agree SpaceX cannt and will not perform 100 or 200 launches even if a mission is successful because of the cost.
The US has a 40T problem today, it cannnot spend trillions on landing a team on Mars.